3 ms·
Well, US originated DMCA notices already don't reach outside the US. If I'm outside US jurisdiction (i.e., I'm not there, won't be there and I'm not a company
by PeterisP 14y ago
Well, US originated DMCA notices already don't reach outside the US.
If I'm outside US jurisdiction (i.e., I'm not there, won't be there and I'm not a company with a branch or sales in USA), then DMCA doesn't apply to me. They might send a notice accidentally, but they generally don't bother since they can be safely ignored and usually are.
The local laws do apply, so USA tried to bundle DMCA-style provisions in some international trade agreements; but in general there are a bunch of things (such as breaking DRM or selling jailbreak kits) that are restricted by DMCA but explicitly legal in many countries.
- dangrossman 14y agoThe DMCA safe harbor provisions apply to service providers, not to their customers. They exist to remove the service provider's liability for unknowingly infringing copyrights -- WordPress is allegedly infringing by distributing this material, not just the author that uploaded it to the blog. What matters here is (a) where the service provider is, not where you are, and (b) whether the service provider wants to be immune to an infringement lawsuit in the US. They may be sued domestically even if a judgement can't be enforced, and they may prefer to do the minimal actions necessary to get the safe harbor protection so their future potential business with the US isn't threatened. Copyright is enforced internationally, and there are many businesses outside the US that will happily comply with the notices. There's no downside, complying turns "you are possibly doing something illegal and could be sued" to "you cannot be sued even if what you're doing is illegal".
- PeterisP 14y agoYes, of course, I'm not talking about customers of third-party service providers - since such customers don't receive DMCA notices, ever. DMCA applies to Automattic who run Wordpress.com, but doesn't reach to the multitude of other Wordpress hosts outside USA. Pure copyright violations are illegal almost everywhere, so non-US entities may likely honor such DMCA notices - although to them, they are just normal complaints/threats with zero effect on whatever safe harbor provisions apply in their country. But for the DMCA-specific provisions (distribution of jailbreaks, console-DRM-mods, etc) they can be ignored if there are no local prohibitions against that.