3 ms·
Well, that should be fixable - if this is an actual DMCA takedown (instead of a simple complaint), then it does come with a mandatory requirement to be 'under p
by PeterisP 14y ago
Well, that should be fixable - if this is an actual DMCA takedown (instead of a simple complaint), then it does come with a mandatory requirement to be 'under penalty of perjury'. Intentional misuse can thus be persecuted, and may get even criminal penalties.
Of course, it's a big question whether they will try to fight it in courts and if DMCA perjury jurisdiction can effectively reach the accused company in India.
- pyre 14y agoIf the perjury jurisdiction can't reach India, then maybe the DMCA notice shouldn't reach the USA. At the very least, it would be a good example case to bring up with your Congress-critter about changing the DMCA.
- belorn 14y agoThat would imply that US originated DMCA notices shouldn't reach outside the US.
- joejohnson 14y agoYeah, maybe they shouldn't.
- pyre 14y agoIf the penalties for abusing the DMCA can't reach outside of the US, then why should the benefits?
- marvin 14y agoI think this was tongue-in-cheek; many in the US (including official people) treat the DMCA as if it was an international law. At the very least, this behavior exists on general copyright issues.
- belorn 14y agoYes. DMCA had for example a real impact on the TPB case in Sweden. Any work that would start implying that DMCA notices should stop at the border, would run into the lobbyists. (I guess I should consider Poe's law a bit more in the future.)
- PeterisP 14y agoWell, US originated DMCA notices already don't reach outside the US. If I'm outside US jurisdiction (i.e., I'm not there, won't be there and I'm not a company with a branch or sales in USA), then DMCA doesn't apply to me. They might send a notice accidentally, but they generally don't bother since they can be safely ignored and usually are. The local laws do apply, so USA tried to bundle DMCA-style provisions in some international trade agreements; but in general there are a bunch of things (such as breaking DRM or selling jailbreak kits) that are restricted by DMCA but explicitly legal in many countries.
- dangrossman 14y agoThe DMCA safe harbor provisions apply to service providers, not to their customers. They exist to remove the service provider's liability for unknowingly infringing copyrights -- WordPress is allegedly infringing by distributing this material, not just the author that uploaded it to the blog. What matters here is (a) where the service provider is, not where you are, and (b) whether the service provider wants to be immune to an infringement lawsuit in the US. They may be sued domestically even if a judgement can't be enforced, and they may prefer to do the minimal actions necessary to get the safe harbor protection so their future potential business with the US isn't threatened. Copyright is enforced internationally, and there are many businesses outside the US that will happily comply with the notices. There's no downside, complying turns "you are possibly doing something illegal and could be sued" to "you cannot be sued even if what you're doing is illegal".
- PeterisP 14y agoYes, of course, I'm not talking about customers of third-party service providers - since such customers don't receive DMCA notices, ever. DMCA applies to Automattic who run Wordpress.com, but doesn't reach to the multitude of other Wordpress hosts outside USA. Pure copyright violations are illegal almost everywhere, so non-US entities may likely honor such DMCA notices - although to them, they are just normal complaints/threats with zero effect on whatever safe harbor provisions apply in their country. But for the DMCA-specific provisions (distribution of jailbreaks, console-DRM-mods, etc) they can be ignored if there are no local prohibitions against that.
- dangrossman 14y agoIt's much simpler than that. To be protected by the safe harbor provision of the DMCA, a service provider must not only promptly disable access to material upon receipt of a notice, they must also promptly re-enable access to that material upon receipt of a counternotice. The original author need only send these notices and the blog posts must be put back up if WordPress wants to be protected from being sued itself for distributing the material. In most cases, this entails nothing more than 2 minutes to copy and paste an e-mail from a readily available template, simply adding in your name and URLs of the content you attest you have permission to publish. The DMCA errs on the side of leaving alleged infringing material online, not the other way around. To force something down, you have to go to court and get a judgement. The perjury statement is actually weaker than it seems. The wording you see in a lot of copy-and-paste notice templates is stronger than is required by the act. You only have to attest under penalty of perjury that you are authorized to act on behalf of the holder of a copyright, not that the contents of your claim are true.
- drucken 14y ago"To get content removed, copyright holder Bob need only claim a good-faith belief that neither he nor the law has authorized the use. Bob is not subject to penalties for perjury. In contrast, to get access to content re-enabled, Alice must claim a good faith belief under penalty of perjury that the material was mistakenly taken down. This allows for copyright holders to send out take-down notices without incurring much liability; to get the sites back up, the recipients might need to expend considerably more resources. Section 510(f) makes the sender of an invalid claim liable for the damages resulting from the content’s improper removal, including legal fees, but that remedy is not always practical. Furthermore, ISP’s tend to remove allegedly offending material immediately, while there is a 10-14 day delay before the ISP re-enables access in response to a counter-notice. For example, if a website advertised an upcoming labor protest outside BlameCo, BlameCo could send a DMCA notice to the site's ISP alleging copyright infringement of their name or logo a week before the protest. The site would then be disabled; even if the site's owners immediately filed a counter-notice, access would not be re-enabled until after the protest, too late to be useful." [1] The behavior described above is consistent with many ISPs, Google and Youtube, for example. In fact, with Youtube's stated policy [2] it is not even clear that without consent from the original "copyright holder" that they will restore content (though from DMCA terms alone they are theoretically legally obliged). Wordpress's stated policy [3] is more direct but no less frustrating for victims of malicious takedown notices. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_Copyright_Infringement_Liability_Limitation_Act#Ineffective_Counter-Notice_Procedure http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_Copyright_Infringement_L... [2]: http://www.youtube.com/yt/copyright/counter-notification.html http://www.youtube.com/yt/copyright/counter-notification.htm... [3]: http://en.support.wordpress.com/content-theft-what-to-do/ http://en.support.wordpress.com/content-theft-what-to-do/