6 ms·
Mistake found in invariant subspace proof
- JackFr 14y agoI find it interesting that the phrase was 'a gap was discovered', rather than 'we discovered a gap' or 'Prof. X discovered a gap.' Assuming they are able to prove it, would that rate a footnote 'We are indebted to Prof. X for pointing out ....'? And also is there a protocol or custom about how long other guys will give them to try to fix it before they try themselves?
- user24 14y agoThat's likely just the academic register. I wrote my dissertation saying "we found that..." when really it should have been "I found that...". Getting the academic tone right in essays/thesis/papers is important and indeed becomes second nature after a while.
- speeder 14y agoImpressive that they admitted the mistake instead of going on full defense and blame something else.
- jgrahamc 14y agoWho could they have blamed? It's a proof: either it holds up to examination or it doesn't.
- speeder 14y agoSome academics enter in denial mode and blabber bullshit. Others just invent convoluted ways to say that whoever pointed them wrong are wrong. Seemly in their case they found out they were wrong themselves and retracted their claims quickly.
- CKKim 14y agoAs a Mathematics graduate I was going to call you out on your comment, because I feel the subject does not lend itself to the kind of wiggle room necessary for maneuvering such as you describe. Then I remembered this: http://www.futilitycloset.com/2013/01/23/the-indiana-pi-bill/ http://www.futilitycloset.com/2013/01/23/the-indiana-pi-bill..., and thought better of it.
- speeder 14y agoHeh, that story is awesome. And remembers me when someone almost conceived politicians to ban "oxide of dihydrogen" from foodstuffs
- jerf 14y agoThe more objective the discipline, the less you see that, because metaphorically, the light is too bright to hide. Mathematics is, arguably, the most objective discipline there is, so I don't think you see much of this. Particle physics is the most concrete of the real physics, so you see admirable scientific discipline there too, for instance, with the recent FTL neutrinos. As you get fuzzier and fuzzier, you get more and more blabbering, until, ahem, eventually the "science" consists of little more than blabber; I'll leave it as an exercise to the reader as to where to draw that line. http://xkcd.com/451/ http://xkcd.com/451/
- knowtheory 14y agoEr. Let's try this a different way. Kant drew two distinctions, Analytic vs Synthetic (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analytic%E2%80%93synthetic_distinction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analytic%E2%80%93synthetic_dist... ) and A Priori vs A Posteriori (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_priori_and_a_posteriori http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_priori_and_a_posteriori ). By Kant's reckoning. Math is Analytic and A Priori, meaning that it is neither dependent on facts about the world, nor does the exploration of math require knowledge of the world to interrogate. You start with some axioms, and you just go from there. Fields like physics are synthetic and a posteriori, and the search for a grand unified theory which pull together the fundamental forces we know about are intellectual endeavors that are about the universe, and contingent upon the nature of the universe. If the universe were different, the facts and conclusions we would arrive at would be different. None of this has to do with objectivity per se. Physics is objective(ish), but it's not an analytical field (as Kant defines it). And you can claim that biology or linguistics or sociology aren't "science". But biology was still a field of scientific inquiry before Watson & Crick, or Darwin (although a less rigorous or well developed field). We have ways to know the world, and we should avail ourselves of them, and endeavor to improve their rigor. So, part of what i'm saying is that it'd be nice if people would stop dismissing other fields as "not science" :P
- thebooktocome 14y agoDr. Cowen works, coincidentally, at the same institution as Dr. Louis de Branges, http://www.math.purdue.edu/~branges/site//Papers http://www.math.purdue.edu/~branges/site//Papers , who has claimed a proof of the Riemann hypothesis for many years now. You can read his "Apology for the Proof of the Riemann hypothesis" (Apology in the sense of "defense") to get an idea of who can be blamed for gaps in proofs. (de Branges also claims a proof of the invariant subspace problem, but since his proof of RH is disputed and his proof of ISP uses the same technique, to my knowledge few people have examined it.)
- cantos 14y agoI guess the alternative would be to claim that your results are incomplete rather than wrong. This does happen from time to time. Vinay Deolalikar claimed a proof that P is not equal to NP which received intense scrutiny online two years ago and multiple errors were found. He has never withdrawn the claim. You can read his non-withdrawal here http://www.hpl.hp.com/personal/Vinay_Deolalikar/ http://www.hpl.hp.com/personal/Vinay_Deolalikar/
- psionski 14y agoI came here to say just that :) Good thing we have set the right expectations in the software industry - everything can be explained by "it's a computer, duh" because users expect everything to be full of bugs anyways :)
- jonjacky 14y agoAnother recent example: Edward Nelson of Princeton retracted his claim of having a proof of the inconsistency of Peano Arithmetic. Replying to Terence Tao, he wrote: "You are quite right, and my original response was wrong. Thank you for spotting my error. I withdraw my claim." http://m-phi.blogspot.com/2011/10/nelson-withdraws-his-claim.html http://m-phi.blogspot.com/2011/10/nelson-withdraws-his-claim... http://m-phi.blogspot.com/2011/10/inconsistency-of-pa-and-consensus-in.html http://m-phi.blogspot.com/2011/10/inconsistency-of-pa-and-co...
- j2kun 14y agoThis is one of the worst things that can happen to a paper of yours, the only worse thing being that it is published before you have to retract it.
- gfodor 14y agoI'd say it'd be worse if someone else found the bug.
- ot 14y agoSome context: the Invariant Subspace Problem is an important open problem in functional analysis [1]. There is a MathOverflow thread discussing its significance [2]. For those not familiar with functional analysis, it is basically a generalization of basic linear algebra fact that, in complex finite-dimensional vector spaces, every matrix (or to be more precise, every linear operator) has at least one eigenvector. Cowen and Gallardo announced [3] that they proved the theorem in December, but apparently the proof is wrong, so the problem is still open. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invariant_subspace_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invariant_subspace_problem [2] http://mathoverflow.net/questions/48908/is-the-invariant-subspace-problem-interesting http://mathoverflow.net/questions/48908/is-the-invariant-sub... [3] http://aperiodical.com/2013/01/the-invariant-subspace-problem-solved-for-hilbert-space/ http://aperiodical.com/2013/01/the-invariant-subspace-proble...
- user24 14y ago> For those not familiar with functional analysis, it is basically a generalization of basic linear algebra fact that, in complex finite-dimensional vector spaces, every matrix (or to be more precise, every linear operator) has at least one eigenvector. Oh, thanks for the clarification.
- dbaupp 14y agoIt helped me, and they (the analogy and OP) seem like something very hard to explain briefly to someone not versed in linear algebra. Edit: clearly it's possible though, as the other replies attest to.
- btilly 14y agoIt is possible to briefly explain enough to people to fool them into thinking that they have a sense of the discussion. However this is a form of intellectual entertainment, and not actual explanation. Several times I began trying to write an actual explanation of what a vector space is, a linear function, a subspace, a Banach space, a Hilbert space, and what the actual conjecture is. I got bogged down every time.