4 ms·
Lately we're finding good arguments for the idea that people start declining in abilities earlier than we thought. At the same time, there's a lot of work bein
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
Lately we're finding good arguments for the idea that people start declining in abilities earlier than we thought.
At the same time, there's a lot of work being done on life extension.
What happens if we extend life to, say, 150 and what we get is this long, 100-year decline into complete cognitive paralysis?
I'm 43 and I don't feel like I'm losing it. In fact, in some ways I feel more cognitively adept than I was at 27. When I was 27 I was quicker on my feet, but there wasn't a depth there. Now, at least to me, I feel that I have a lot more weight to my decisions and actions. I dunno - tough subject. It could be, like the pot discussion, that I simply feel this way.
I do know that if cognitive decline is going to be defined as starting in the late 20s, we're going to start seeing a lot of middle-aged people getting medicated for age-related cognitive issues in the near future.
- randallsquared 18y agoAnd about your last point: this is a good thing. :) I can't wait.
- jwilliams 18y agoLately we're finding good arguments for the idea that people start declining in abilities earlier than we thought. I got the impression that the research was going the other way. A lot of current research reporting seems to indicate brain plasticity is broader and longer-lasting than we thought. Course. I'm 27+ so a bit of bias might be creeping in.
- shiranaihito 18y agoThat's what I've heard too - our brains are supposed to stay in good shape much longer than our bodies.
- sown 18y agoWhat happens if we extend life to, say, 150 and what we get is this long, 100-year decline into complete cognitive paralysis? I think if they can make you live forever, they can also probably preserve your brain, too.
- ErrantX 18y agoSome people are talking about the first person to live to 1000 being alive today... so, a 900 year decline? :) I think whilst you have a point you also neglect to factor in that with medical developments extending life we will also end up with developments in mental care/extension.
- russell 18y agoWisdom is what it's called. After 40 your reflexes are slower and you are less likely to have your world shattering idea. OTOH you are probably a better judge of probabilities of success/failure, people's capabilities, and allocation of resources. Lot's of people are significant contributors into their 70's. I dont think living to 150 means being 80 for 80 years. Probably middle age get stretched forever and the decline is about as fast and as long as it is now.
- amichail 18y agoAfter 40 your reflexes are slower and you are less likely to have your world shattering idea. For some people, creativity increases with age. But still, quick thinking and high energy levels are useful. I think it's crucial that we compress schooling as much as possible so people can do something important while they still can.
- aceofspades19 18y agoI find it frustrating that most people spend a quarter of their life just going to school and you essentially can't do anything that useful until you are at least 25 or so
- harpastum 18y agoI find it much more frustrating that the common concept is that once you finish your formal schooling, you're done learning. As much as listening to lectures for 20 years can be tedious, schools are a compression (time) and expansion (breadth) of the discoveries we would make on our own, and are therefore simply a way to get people up to speed with the current world. The real learning starts after school is out.
- furbearntrout 18y agoi think creativity increases as you have more experiences (plural) to draw inspiration from.
- 18y ago
- jodrellblank 18y agoWhat happens if we extend life to, say, 150 and what we get is this long, 100-year decline into complete cognitive paralysis? We go "That's interesting, I wonder which processes are involved and how we can keep their desirable effects while removing or reversing the decline?" I'm late 20s and I do feel like I'm losing it. I feel overloaded by the infohose of 'news' I skim read every day yet mostly forget completely very quickly, lacking any rigorous understanding of significant subject(s), and facing paralysis of choice of all the things that might be worth spending 10 years studying. More weight to my decisions? I think it's more inertia and more deeply worn ruts and grooves and more deeply implanted patterns of automatically triggered response that are 'me'.
- unalone 18y agoI'm 18, and occasionally I feel like I've lost something I had before. But that's a common feeling, I'm sure: I'll always want to be wiser and simultaneously younger. I doubt that has anything at all to do with my actual age or level of knowledge. The feeling of losing things may very well stem from the inertia that builds up in life, along with your own growing awareness of your abilities. When I was 5 I thought I was a superhero: I was powerful and could crush anything. When I was 16, I didn't think that, but I thought that I was a powerful, fascinating individual around whom the world revolved. Now I've begun working out and taking care of myself, and I'm probably stronger now than I've ever been, but I don't have the same blind, false confidence I had before. Is that losing it? I'll suspect that a year from now if I continue to work out with any level of dedication, I'll be stronger than I've ever been - not just in my mind, but in reality. Similarly, every year I become more aware of my limitations, but simultaneously those limitations lessen and disappear. I'm brighter now than I've ever been, and it's my intent never to enter a life scenario where I'm not allowed to continue to grow. Inertia is the larger problem: both with body and mind and personality, the longer you don't use something the more it fades away. By your late 20s, you've left school, you've entered a more stable type of living, and there's every chance that you're in a duller, more monotonous setting - and worse, you're faced with the prospect of things never abruptly changing. That's deadly, and I'd suspect it contributes a lot to this attitude of people burning out. (I come from a slightly unique perspective - the world of writing, where if you publish a book before you're 35 you're considered precocious. In all of literature, the greatest changes have come from people older than 30. I think it's because literature, unlike other forms of music, is forced to be subtle in order to work: it requires command of only a few skills, and there's no pressure to hurry with writing, and so as a result the field is full of people who can dedicate a decade to a single piece. The works that are remembered are the ones so rich with experience that they stand above even this field of work. Unlike, say, music, where not knowing anything means you have an advantage in your ability to create new works, literature very often requires at least an understanding of what's been done before, because without it the chances of your making something worth people's time is virtually nil.)
- davidmathers 18y ago"What happens if we extend life to, say, 150 and what we get is this long, 100-year decline into complete cognitive paralysis?" Struldbrugs: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Struldbrug http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Struldbrug