4 ms·
Study: Old Age Begins at 27
- Allocator2008 18y agoIf true, and I don't know enough about this area to comment, but if so, it seems for optimum gene selection, people should procreate (or at least freeze their genetic material in a lab for future use) prior to this age. I have often thought that perhaps the rise in mental disorders in children such as autism could be related to people waiting until later in life to have children, at which point, their DNA has already begun to break down. Studies showing that the oldest child in a family tends to also have a higher IQ is consistent with this. The younger you are when you reproduce, the more fit your genes are, and therefore the smarter, healthier, etc. your children are likely to be. Economic pressures now make people wait until later to reproduce than they did a generation or two ago, but this could be counteracted by saving genetic material in a lab when one is young, then later, when one is economically ready to reproduce, one can make use of the stored material to do so. It is unlikely in the near future that people will all of a sudden want to go back to having kids right out of high school, so, for optimum gene selection, they should at least save off their genetic material (sperm, eggs) for future use. Otherwise, going forward, the average intelligence of the populace is likely to decline.
- tokenadult 18y agoWhat you say is consistent with what I said in my comment. I would point out, regarding storing genetic material, that I think the studies so far have not shown a large enough effect size from age on sperm to be sure that storing sperm (which has its own damaging effects in some cases) results in a better trade-off. But the general evolutionary picture would favor marrying and reproducing at younger rather than older ages.
- menloparkbum 18y agoI don't know enough about this area to comment The study you're thinking of about the oldest child having a higher IQ (3 points higher on average) made a point that it was nurture, not nature.
- russell 18y agoI think that, from the kid's point of view, it's better to be born to parents in their 30's. The genetic risk is small, but more than offset by the maturity and improved economic circumstances of the parents. It's not until the late 30's or 40's that genetic decline starts to be a serious risk.
- Allocator2008 18y agoThe fact remains if IQ is tapering off in the late 20's, the a child born to the parents in their 30's may not have as high an IQ as the parents. Personally my parents were in their mid-20's when I crawled out of the evolutionary slime, and in a sense I agree with you on the maturity and economic front - both factors were issues - and I think there has been growth there since, and my younger siblings had it better as far as maturity went, but honestly I wouldn't have it any other way, at least I know I got the best evolutionary shot I could get, lol! :-)
- tokenadult 18y agoThis makes sense. Most Paleolithic members of the species Homo sapiens were dead by age forty, so there hasn't been much selection pressure to favor human beings preserving health or their faculties much past that age. I'm living on borrowed time, being almost twice as old as the headlined age. On the other hand, some people decline more or less rapidly, and from a better or worse base, so fifty-year-olds can still outsmart twenty-seven-year-olds in specific cases. "However, the report published in the academic journal Neurobiology Of Ageing, found that abilities based on accumulated knowledge, such as performance on tests of vocabulary or general information, increased until at the age of 60." Live life to the fullest while you can appreciate it.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoLately we're finding good arguments for the idea that people start declining in abilities earlier than we thought. At the same time, there's a lot of work being done on life extension. What happens if we extend life to, say, 150 and what we get is this long, 100-year decline into complete cognitive paralysis? I'm 43 and I don't feel like I'm losing it. In fact, in some ways I feel more cognitively adept than I was at 27. When I was 27 I was quicker on my feet, but there wasn't a depth there. Now, at least to me, I feel that I have a lot more weight to my decisions and actions. I dunno - tough subject. It could be, like the pot discussion, that I simply feel this way. I do know that if cognitive decline is going to be defined as starting in the late 20s, we're going to start seeing a lot of middle-aged people getting medicated for age-related cognitive issues in the near future.
- randallsquared 18y agoAnd about your last point: this is a good thing. :) I can't wait.
- jwilliams 18y agoLately we're finding good arguments for the idea that people start declining in abilities earlier than we thought. I got the impression that the research was going the other way. A lot of current research reporting seems to indicate brain plasticity is broader and longer-lasting than we thought. Course. I'm 27+ so a bit of bias might be creeping in.
- shiranaihito 18y agoThat's what I've heard too - our brains are supposed to stay in good shape much longer than our bodies.
- sown 18y agoWhat happens if we extend life to, say, 150 and what we get is this long, 100-year decline into complete cognitive paralysis? I think if they can make you live forever, they can also probably preserve your brain, too.
- 18y ago
- radu_floricica 18y ago> Twenty-seven has long had negative connotations, as it is the age at which many popular musicians died, including Jimi Hendrix, Jim Morrison, Brian Jones, Janis Joplin and Kurt Cobain. Twenty seven is an interesting age. This much I knew for years before reaching it, and turned out to be true. I don't really know why, but it sortof makes sense. It's when you go from being a young man to a real adult. Strangely though, for me it was not filled with responsabilities, on the contrary.
- wallflower 18y agoIt's never too late to start anything - developing yourself is a function of time and passion: http://www.unlikelysalsero.com/2007/08/magic-of-time-last-one-standing.html http://www.unlikelysalsero.com/2007/08/magic-of-time-last-on... "The unexamined life is not worth living." -Socrates, in Plato, Dialogues, Apology No matter what age you are, I think this is important. How often (daily? weekly?) do you think about your self image, attitudes, actions, beliefs, relationships, and recurring thoughts? I didn't want to get all Mike Litman on you but..
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- juanpablo 18y agoI don't buy it. I suspect that it is more related to dull/stressful work environments than age (at 22 you're either still in college or fresh out from it).
- Xichekolas 18y agoDid they test the same people at all these ages? No. So yeah, environment/upbringing/schooling could have a huge impact it seems. At least if you believe that skills like this can be kept 'in shape' with frequent use (which I do believe).
- yters 18y agoAlso, mental dexterity and knowledge are probably inversely proportional to each other because once you learn more you draw on more to make decisions. So, if we could rid our minds of our knowledge we might improve our thinking speed. Anyways, for people who feel down about their age, remember that nothing anybody does will last forever. Our judgment of significance is significantly colored by our finite sense of time. Just think of what seemed like a long time to you at 3 vs at 30. Thus, it is ok to primarily aim at happiness in this life instead of achievement, though aiming at achievement is also good if it makes you happy.
- TTDaVeTT 18y agoRegardless of thinking speed, the more you know, the better you think. You are able to analyze a given situation or problem more effectively because you can draw on past experience or knowledge and make a more informed decision. I would happily take an 'experienced' brain over a young on that is faster (if thats even true, which i dont really believe...).
- juliend2 18y agoI only hope that my age will not keep me from learning new things. The most important thing when learning is to keep a good attitude. I believe that the brain can be trained to get smarter at all ages.
- Rexxar 18y agoIt's may be a problem of training. A lot of people stop learning new things when then leave university so their brain could become less efficient. Correlation don't imply causality. There is not enough facts to convince me.
- msie 18y agoSigh, I wasted the best years of my life in a startup that didn't get me rich. ;)
- mxcl 18y agoSounds like there's a story there. Care to tell?
- keltecp11 18y agoI refuse to believe this.
- weiser 18y agoOk, so certain mental abilities deteriorate. Maybe, some other mental abilities improve. The problem with this research is that it is trying look at brain from a certain view point, ignoring all other view points. A more holistic approach would provide a better understanding of how mental abilities change over time.
- nraynaud 18y agook, my next startup will be selling suicide gears for 29+ people ...
- rafa8a 18y agoDamn, I only have 4 years left.
- aneesh 18y ago"Researchers have found that peoples' mental abilities peak at 22 before beginning to deteriorate just five years later." The 5-year gap doesn't make sense. If you're at your peak at age 22, wouldn't you, by definition, begin to decline immediately after? :-) I suppose you could level off for 5 years, but then it's misleading to call 22 a "peak".
- ricmorton 18y agoIn case anyone is worried about their twenty-something cognitive performance, bear in mind that the refutation of this study will probably not surface in the media; http://medicine.plosjournals.org/perlserv/?request=get-document&doi=10.1371%2Fjournal.pmed.0020124&ct=1 http://medicine.plosjournals.org/perlserv/?request=get-docum... -An unconcerned twenty-something ;)
- alecco 18y agoTry one of those mind training games for a couple of months and you'll see how lame this kind of study is.
- mxcl 18y agoYou sum up most of the stupid attitudes in this thread. The scientists in this study most likely are better at this field than you. Probably The Times misinterpreted the results. Still your denial is hilarious. Just because you're smart, doesn't make you right. That goes for all of you.
- alecco 18y agoI'm not a neuroscientist. But I'm an avid reader of neuroscience blogs (not the shiny ones, the ones by and for scientists) and papers. The Torygraph isn't exactly qualitity media but I doubt they misinterpreted the paper that bad. The problem with current research is it's requiring too much previous knowledge to grasp even the abstract. And it's getting more granular and harder to sell with mainstream headlines. I actually prefer it this way. There is a large amount of neuroscience research from the last decade that didn't make it to mainstream media. Specially things that could offend people or cults. Mainstream media is obsolete because of this. A small blog post with proper explanations as popups or links to references (even Wikipedia) delivers more efficiently.
- pekka 18y agoSo true, It is a known fact among the chess players that the ability to calculate ahead peaks at the age of 27.
- dgordon 18y agoNo it isn't. Everything I've heard suggests that chess players tend to peak around their mid-30s, and then you have Viktor Korchnoi, who won the Soviet junior championship at 16, was playing for the world championship at 50, and was rated 85th in the world at 75. His 78th birthday is coming up next week.
- old-gregg 18y agoMaybe... Let me share my personal experience: when I was 18-21 I struggled with advanced math in college. Now, at 30, when I re-open those books just for fun, everything makes so much sense and some aspects of it are even enjoyable. I've failed to find a plausible explanation for myself. I haven't done much math (calculus, probability, statistics) since graduation, yet the exact same books are so much easier to read now. I experienced a similar effect much earlier in my life: I struggled with understanding recursive algorithms when I was 12, but when I came back to them at 16 I laughed at myself - it suddenly seemed so trivial.
- mxcl 18y agoWell honestly, this was a statistical study. Still those of us who are 27 are glad to hear you part anyway! Damn. I don't want to have passed my prime.
- wheels 18y agoAlso anecdotal, but... As I started getting into heavy research on recommender systems for our startup after being somewhat lax in my research reading for a few years I stumbled into some papers that were really hard for me to push through. I kept thinking, "I must be slipping, I know this stuff wasn't as hard for me in college." Then at some point I needed to look up a couple things in some of my textbooks (I saved them all) and as soon as I picked them up I thought ... wait? That was the hard stuff? This is all so ... trivial. Since the progression from textbooks to academic papers had mostly come at some remove, I'd not noticed that I was gradually reading much harder material, to the point that the stuff that I found hard in computer science in college now seems all rather easy. Now, I'm 28 at this point, but already I've noticed that I'm not as fast as I once was, but I've got more momentum. When I throw myself at a problem it's with the goal of crushing it rather than dancing around it. This seems to be what's awesome about smart folks that are in middle to older ages. There's like this blunt force of knowledge that can be thrown at hard problems. Great systems programmers in their 50s are awesome to work with. Note, also, that the article also mentions that knowledge based abilities increase up until you're 60.
- mechanical_fish 18y agoOnce you've got an intuitive picture of how something works, you will find that the details just fall into place. But often that intuitive picture can't just be gifted to you, despite the best efforts of our best teachers to concoct the perfect metaphors. It takes time. You have to fiddle around with the concepts in your head, sometimes for years, before they really sink in. You might have to repeat them several times, or approach them from several angles, or encounter them in unusual surroundings, or find the one book that finally explains the subject in a way that clicks. Once you really understand something, trying to remember what it was like before you understood it is like trying to forget how to read.
- ars 18y agoIf the peak is at 22, we are really short changing our children by setting the age of majority at 18.
- Eliezer 18y agoNo frickin' kidding.
- jaymstr 18y agoI'm 23. I'm going to reference this research when we pitch our company to raise money. Fund the young guys.
- brlewis 18y agoThat's a good idea. And if you're still pitching when you get older, you can reference this other study about the brain peaking at 39: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=345785 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=345785
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoNever trust anybody over 30, man http://www.bartleby.com/73/1828.html http://www.bartleby.com/73/1828.html
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- morbidkk 18y agoMay be Its fault of education systems and corporate jobs..I don't buy it for sure
- danbmil99 18y agoWho cares if your clock slows down say 20% by 50? Think how easy it is to optimize any program by 20%. It's irrelevant. Much more important is what software you're running. Like other posters here, I struggled with things in my 'prime' that I now find much easier. That phenomenon doesn't seem to get talked about much. There seems to be this truism that intellectually challenging work peaks before 30. How many great novels or plays were written by anyone in their 20's? Yet important math and music is often done young. Go figure.
- unalone 18y agoI dunno about novels or plays, but Orson Welles was 25 when he made Citizen Kane. I think it all matters on how accessible the medium is to young people. Modern music is VERY accessible, because there are so few limitations that you can really do whatever you want and while it may not be good, you've got a better chance of its being so since the concepts behind music are comparatively simple. If we were talking about the world of composition, on the other hand, things would be much different. I doubt that we'd see many young brilliant composers, unless they were Mozarts (i.e. helped along heavily by parents).
- neilo 18y agoCarp, no wunder Im dum nwo