3 ms·
A quote from the article: "... and especially since 2005, when Lawrence H. Summers, then president of Harvard, made his notorious comments about women’s aptitud
by lutusp 14y ago
A quote from the article: "... and especially since 2005, when Lawrence H. Summers, then president of Harvard, made his notorious comments about women’s aptitude ..."
This is a gross misreading of history. Summers didn't make a disparaging comment about women's mathematical or scientific aptitude, he merely commented on a theory that men and women have the same average IQ, but different standard deviations in their scores.
The theory is that men and women have the same average IQ, a view supported by much research, but men's IQ standard deviation (deviation from the mean) is larger, which means the population of men includes more individuals who are both smarter and dumber than women, but with the same average value.
The theory is discussed in some depth here (scroll down to "The Trait-Spread Theory"):
http://arachnoid.com/artificial_womb/index.html#Gender_Issues http://arachnoid.com/artificial_womb/index.html#Gender_Issue...
Graphic:
http://arachnoid.com/artificial_womb/graphics/population_curve.png http://arachnoid.com/artificial_womb/graphics/population_cur...
Summers' comments on this theory were widely misinterpreted as suggesting that women were't as smart as men, Summers couldn't extinguish the resulting brush fire, and he was forced out of his post as president of Harvard.
In short, it seems Summers overestimated the intelligence of his audience. There was nothing disparaging about his remarks, but they were perhaps a bit too technical for a public presentation for nonspecialists.
- jacobolus 14y agoThis is silly revisionism. Summers was forced out of his post because he had spent years antagonizing all sorts of people at Harvard, and therefore had many enemies within the faculty. The comments about women were (a) an incredibly stupid thing for a university president to say,† and (b) a convenient pretext for getting rid of him. † Any statement that can be easily interpreted or misinterpreted as offensive is a stupid mistake for a university president.
- lutusp 14y agoThat may all be true, but the theory isn't itself in any way disparaging to women. You've listed some reasons for the consequences of his remarks, but this shouldn't reflect on the theory itself, or justify the claim that Summers' remarks merit the description "notorious comments about women’s aptitude."
- jrkelly 14y agoHow is the theory not disparaging to women? Society is run by people at the edge of the bell curve, if you say that there are less women at the edges than you are saying that it's no big deal we have less women in high-ranking positions.
- hashmymustache 14y agoWhat theory says society is run by people at the edge of the bell curve? Edit: though if you mean politicians then you're right, they're definitely at the edge - just the wrong edge. Bzing!
- jrkelly 14y agoFine, to be more specific -- he was referring to lack of women "in tenured positions in science and engineering at top universities and research institutions". IMO, people assume those positions are held by people that score well on traditional IQ tests. He was basically saying, it's OK we don't see women there -- it's in the biology, there aren't women at the edges of the bell curve. That's pretty disparaging. Edit: hah, yes I agree on politics.
- rohern 14y agoI know nothing about this theory nor about the biology of human intelligence, but someone suggesting a scientific hypothesis is doing science whether or not you like the implications. Go yell at Darwin for implying that a Creator is unnecessary. Someone saying "women are dumb and therefore don't get jobs" would indeed be disparaging women, but proposing a hypothesis about the biology of intelligence is not.
- hashmymustache 14y agoOk I'll bite. I think the issue should focus on remedying the culture, regardless of whether boys dominate the ends. I will gently mention that boys are 5x as likely to have autism or lie within an autistic spectrum disorder loosely characterized by poor socialization skills and obsessive, repetitive behavior. They're (we're) also wired on testosterone which has different effects on the brain. I'm not saying that proves anything, but there's no point denying at the very least statistically observed tendencies in neurodevelopment. Separately, people tenured in STEM positions score well, but they don't have the best grades or IQs. They are often there because they knew the right people, can argue for grants (ie their own relevance and skills), and work their asses off writing papers. I wish they were the smartest, but more often I've encountered narcissists who try to put their names on everything because it's the only way toward promotion (don't blame the player, blame the game). When it comes to women, many grew up being told that if they do poorly in math/science it's ok because they're girls - this is AWFUL both immediately and downstream. Girls become more likely to blame bad performance on their sex and give up whereas guys blame bad performance as a fluke. In STEM fields, you encounter failure ALL the time, it sucks and you feel like a complete idiot. You just have to fight through it, and you're more likely to continue to fight if you aren't told you failed because of your sex. It's obviously a much more complicated issue than what I laid out. It's a very tricky area riddled with people too easily offended or who capitalize on misquotes for political gain. Like I said, whether or not trends are biological or environmental, people should be told to pursue their dreams (it's not like I would tell some white kid playing basketball that he shouldn't dream of going pro because he's not as well represented or if he fails it's because he's white). Yes, that's a false equivalency, but demonstrates societal expectations from seemingly biological premises. For context I'll add that I'm a guy who majored in engineering at a state school while my girlfriend graduated top 5 in her class at princeton in chemistry - we get into debates about this stuff all the time. I'm SO SORRY for using this as forum to rant. Please forgive me HN.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]