4 ms·
Imagine how much more awesome this will be when we also have IPv6. We will have no more need for things like ICE [1], just direct point to point communication.
by IgorPartola 14y ago
Imagine how much more awesome this will be when we also have IPv6. We will have no more need for things like ICE [1], just direct point to point communication. Oh, and multicast for giant video chat sessions.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interactive_Connectivity_Establishment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interactive_Connectivity_Establ...
- loeg 14y agoMulticast on the internet is a nice dream. Will it actually happen with IPv6? My understanding is there is a barrier to adoption — basically all routers involved need to be aware of the multicast initiation/join/leave protocol, and basically, there's a bunch of old hardware/software out there that isn't aware. Is all IPv6-capable hardware capable of this (given that IPv6 came out in ... 1998)?
- 0x0 14y agoI had the impression that the biggest hurdle for multicast to happen on the internet is the insane memory requirements for routers to track all the multicast memberships (as well as being extremely open for abuse -- imagine one client subscribing to every multicast stream out there and never leaving, that would flood the incoming pipes for that ISP)
- __alexs 14y agoIPv6 is also pretty much a requirement due to the whole multicast MAC address collision thing I believe.
- Ironlink 14y agoWhile I don't know anything about how multicast is specified, I would certainly hope that it is possible to implement in such a way that each router only needs to track the memberships of it's direct neighbors. They would then themselves advertise that membership in order to serve their neighbor's request. As for the abusive client, I say if the ISP has any sense of self preservation, they should be interested to police this themselves. For example, knowing how much bandwidth the client is paying for, they could refuse additional or even cut existing memberships of that client once that limit is reached.
- wmf 14y agoThe problem is that a router's direct neighbors may be subscribed to millions of multicast groups and nobody has enough TCAM to track those memberships.
- temp453463343 14y agoThat's never going to happen b/c there is too much legacy infrastructure and the benefit is marginal. All current home routers are configured to do NAT, so you're not going to be able to have a Skype 2.0 be P2P b/c then you'd need to explain to millions of people how to reconfigure their routers. Also P2P opens a whole new can of worms when it comes to security.
- IgorPartola 14y ago> That's never going to happen b/c there is too much legacy infrastructure and the benefit is marginal. It is going to have to happen, or there will be no internet. > All current home routers are configured to do NAT, so you're not going to be able to have a Skype 2.0 be P2P b/c then you'd need to explain to millions of people how to reconfigure their routers. Current home routers will be replaced within a year or two. They do not last that long. Some people are starting to not have dedicated routers, instead renting equipment from the ISPs. > Also P2P opens a whole new can of worms when it comes to security. Firewalls have been around for a long time. We'll survive.
- ttflee 14y agoI'm quite pessimistic about the infrastructure, considering the speed of acceptance of IPv6.
- temp453463343 14y agoYou're also assuming that there won't be NAT with IPv6; I don't know that that is a safe assumption. "Current home routers will be replaced within a year or two." Yeah right! My grandma isn't gunna be changing her router. And she'll be pissed if her stuff stopped working. At then end of the day, if you have the choice between making a NAT friendly product that everyone can use and a non NAT friendly product that has some extra privacy - you'll be choosing the NAT friendly option. "Firewalls have been around for a long time." The thing in windows that everyone disables? NAT is transparent and fool proof. How can you ensure a 3rd party won't be able to connect to your fancy new P2P chat client? Security holes are pervasive in networking code so without NAT and a with a bit of sloppy code, the "bad guys" can at any time connect directly to your computer. Can you imagine the chaos that would happen if there was a zero day bug in a P2P Skype. With NAT 99% of your problems are gone. It's physically impossible to connect to a computer that doesn't have port forwarding. Unless the US gov't comes in an enforces a switch to IPv6 (like it did with digital TVs and all those subsidized converter boxes) directly connecting to computers isn't going to happen.