6 ms·
Not a very useful comment. Depression was not the issue according to someone much closer to the situation than you. Are his parents depressed? No, I know them
by wglb 14y ago
Not a very useful comment.
Depression was not the issue according to someone much closer to the situation than you.
Are his parents depressed? No, I know them both. They are not depressed. Were his grandparents depressed? No. I knew his grandfather.
- rayiner 14y agoYou just don't like the implications of the facts. If you took 100 people and put them in the same situation, the vast majority of them wouldn't have killed themselves. People face longer sentences and the prospect of being imprisoned among violent offenders everyday without killing themselves. The fact is that suicides are statistically aberrational behavior, even among people in high-stress situations. There are lots of factors that lead to suicides, not just the final stressor that might precipitate them. Our standard of blame cannot be so lax as to hold people accountable for atypical reactions to situations.
- wglb 14y ago>You just don't like the implications of the facts. I am not sure you are willing to be acquainted with the facts, regardless of how they are presented or who presents them. I don't think you are close enough to the facts of the situation to speak with such resounding authority about them.
- rayiner 14y agoDid it occur to you that the facts with which you are acquainted are not the relevant ones? Indeed, if you're talking about laying the blame for Aaron's suicide on the feet of Carmen Ortiz, isn't it patently ridiculous to consider the intimate facts of his situation relevant? Are we now to charge prosecutors with being sensitive to the details of the personal lives of the people which they prosecute?
- knowtheory 14y agoDude, you're being that guy. Don't be that guy. Why shouldn't a prosecutor consider the personal circumstance of the accused? Certainly this is done in a variety of ways in the law, the decision as to whether a crime has been committed, the decision as to whether to charge an individual, what charges are brought against that individual. Particularly in the case where prosecutors have wide discretion, such as in the case of computer crimes, the question really should be, on what basis are prosecutors making decisions? And in the event that prosecutors are making capricious or unjust, or disproportionate decisions, then shouldn't they be faced with the consequences of their actions? Shouldn't they consider that they can both ruin and in some cases contribute to the end of someone's life? Even if you don't think this is part of jurisprudence per se, do we not have an obligation to our fellow man?
- rayiner 14y ago"That guy" in what sense? The one that thinks that it's not justifiable to accuse someone of causing someone else to kill themselves? I'm making a moral argument, not a jurisprudential one. We are responsible for the consequences of our actions, but our obligation to our fellow man is circumscribed by context and reasonable expectations. There may be situations in which it is reasonable to expect someone to kill himself, but this was not one of those situations. Carmen Ortiz cannot be held responsible, morally, for someone's unreasonable reaction to her actions. There are things you can hold her responsible for, morally, but suicide is not one of them.
- knowtheory 14y ago"That guy" in the sense that the case you're making sounds very much as if you are contradicting people who do have intimate knowledge of Aaron Swartz's situation. Your case is that the culpability for Swartz's death rests solely with Swartz. Swartz's friends and family have asserted with unanimity that Swartz's life was dominated by this prosecution. Ergo, the series of events culminating in Swartz's suicide would not have happened had he not been prosecuted, or, more importantly, prosecuted in this particular way. When you assert that Ortiz's office is not culpable, it sounds very much like you are contradicting the prosecution's role in Swartz's life and death.
- xijuan 14y agoHow much a stressor is stressful to a person is subjective. For a psychopath who always had troubles with the law to face longer sentences, he/she probably wouldn't feel as stressful as Aaron did. In Aaron's case, he is NOT ONLY dealing with depressed feelings. He is also dealing with a lot of anger due to the injustice.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y ago>People face longer sentences and the prospect of being imprisoned among violent offenders everyday without killing themselves. Some of those people grow up in a culture that prepares them for the possibility that they will be jailed, even possibly unjustly imprisoned.
- oh_sigh 14y agoAnd I don't think that those are the people that the OP was referring to.
- oh_sigh 14y agoYour comment is less useful, and more wrong than the comment you were replying to. > Depression was not the issue according to someone much closer to the situation than you. So what? Closeness doesn't mean you automatically understand a situation. In fact, an argument could be made that closeness can blind people to objective reasoning about a subject. > Are his parents depressed? No, I know them both. Were his grandparents depressed? No. I knew his grandfather. The person you were replying to wasn't implying that his parents are or ever were depressed. He was saying that there is a strong genetic component to depression. Please research "recessive traits". Let me rephrase your argument to Tay-Sachs disease: "How could he lack the haxosaminidase A protein? His parents did not lack the haxosaminidase A protein, and neither did his grandparents".