3 ms·
so you have these rights but the govenment can over rule it for "public interest" or "as necessary in a democratic society" I am sure that the Chinese leaders
by walshemj 14y ago
so you have these rights but the govenment can over rule it for "public interest" or "as necessary in a democratic society"
I am sure that the Chinese leaders would say that the labour camps are "as necessary in a democratic society"
Oh and that old chestnut its for the children
- Drakim 14y agoThere isn't a nation on earth that doesn't have some workaround, be it martial law or these special clauses. Adding that it is only for things that are necessary in a democratic society is a good touch, because it makes it harder to make arbitrary restrictions because it's for the "general public good".
- walshemj 14y agooh I agree but who defines what is "necessary" and looking at the nordic states (iclelands constitution is based on the danish constitution) they can be very communitarian and the down side of those systems sis they can be very unforgiving of outsiders and those that do not fit in.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- saraid216 14y agoI didn't do more than read the first page or two, but there appears to be a Supreme Court. Presumably, it's their job. That's generally how these things work.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jessaustin 14y agoIt would not be possible to draft a law that did away with these natural tensions in an easy and robust way. The lines must be drawn piecemeal, with deference to but not bound by precedent. At least in this the tensions are made explicit in a way that even unsophisticated citizens can understand. (Not that any particular citizen will understand it, cf. the many Americans who completely elide "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times" from the Copyright Clause.) Eventually the nation will have the legal system the citizens demand (or is that deserve?), the laws on the books be damned. The rule of law is a tradition more than it is a text.