4 ms·
> It costs nothing Doesn't it costs you anything to make a transaction with Bitcoin? That was more than I knew.
by diggan 14y ago
> It costs nothing
Doesn't it costs you anything to make a transaction with Bitcoin? That was more than I knew.
- jerguismi 14y agoThe fee system is pretty complicated. You can get some transactions through without a fee, but I doubt that this will be the case in the future, when transaction spam will be increasing. The required fee basically depends on the generated transaction size (in bytes).
- yuvadam 14y agoThe costs are negligible - several cents per transaction nowadays, and is always up to you to define related to how important the transaction is and how fast you'd like the network to confirm it. In any case, the costs are miniscule compared to standard transaction fees that banks charge.
- gst 14y agoThe costs are neglible now, but based on how Bitcoin works (shared transaction list) it seems likely that the costs will rise in the future: 1) Currently there's a transaction size limit of 1 MB in the protocol, with typical "large" transaction sizes being about one third of this. Once average transaction sizes will hit the limit, miners will probably include transactions paying higher fees, thus auctioning the available space. 2) Even if Bitcoin users agree on a protocol change to increase this limit costs will rise, as every transaction needs to be forwarded to all other nodes (or at least to the miners). So increasing transaction sizes will create higher hardware requirements for miners, without necessarily increasing their income. And there's the further complication that a fork will only work if a majority of the network actually supports it.
- MacsHeadroom 14y ago1) No, Gavin (Bitcoin lead developer) says he wants to make the transaction and block size unlimited (or rather, let the miners limit it). This should keep fees down. https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=140233.40 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=140233.40 2) No, costs for the majority of transactions will not go up- in fact, they may go down. Most miners already charge different fees based on any given transaction's size. The fees range from about a half-cent USD to about two cents USD. If someone wants to send a 2MB transaction, the miners will be able to charge whatever transaction fee they choose for expedient processing.
- MacsHeadroom 14y ago1) No, Gavin (Bitcoin lead developer) says he wants to make the transaction and block size unlimited (or rather, let the miners limit it). This should keep fees down. https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=140233.40 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=140233.40 2) No, costs for the majority of transactions will not go up- in fact, they may go down. Most miners already charge different fees based on any given transaction's size. The fees range from about a half-cent USD to about two cents USD. If someone wants to send a 2MB transaction, the miners will be able to charge whatever transaction fee they choose for expedient processing.
- Tuna-Fish 14y agoA simple explanation is that each time a new block is created ("mined"), the miner puts some or all of the outstanding transactions in the block, which "executes" them. The miner is allowed to pick which of those transactions he wants to include using any criteria he wants. A person making a btc transaction can add "transaction fees" to the transaction, effectively making a second transaction to the miner of the block who accepts his transaction. This allows for a simple anti-spam/prioritization feature: The miner sorts outstanding transactions by transaction fees offered, and puts the top n txns into the block. The total volume of transactions that are handled by the system is designed to be large enough to be practical for all and any uses. This means that at the moment if someone isn't embedding files in the block chain or something (BTCfs is a real thing!), transactions without fees will still typically be executed eventually.
- oleganza 14y agoI've edited the line: it costs "almost nothing". Comparing to the amounts exchanged and comparing to alternative systems, it is much-much cheaper. And today you can pay zero fees for your transactions and still get them included in the block without significant delay.