4 ms·
> Circumventing conventional DRM isn’t quite this easy, but no DRM scheme has withstood serious efforts to circumvent it. This "truism" is vague, and therefore
by stcredzero 14y ago
> Circumventing conventional DRM isn’t quite this easy, but no DRM scheme has withstood serious efforts to circumvent it.
This "truism" is vague, and therefore misleading in some way. Before Sony decided to piss off the entire internet, their DRM stood for the better part of a year. Motorola's had some phones that weren't rootable for months on end. In one sense, it's true: the economic forces will ensure that everything highly visible and in high demand will have any DRM broken. What entrepreneurs should notice, is that not everything is subject to the same economic forces.
There is a valuable analogy in physical locks. Since the industrial revolution, inventors produce a constant supply of new lock designs which get broken by clever locksmiths. Nothing stands forever. Yet, people still make money selling locks, and they have actual utility. Most of the possible uses for locks are for content which is far less known and far less sought after than someone's rare Ferrari or the bragging rights on the newest lock at the world expo.
Many would say digital goods are different. I say that's primarily wishful thinking. Cash is highly fungible, but is still successfully secured with chintzy little locks in many cases. I think it's high time for people to get their own DRM. It's hopeless for big corporations, but ordinary people are actually in the right economic position to benefit from DRM.
- MichaelGG 14y agoThis old argument? The difference is that with safes/locks, every thief needs to overcome the lock, and there is usually other safeguards. With digital goods, one master cracker does the work once, and everyone else can just download that directly. Also, with cash, you don't hand over the entire box to someone and say "you can only take a few dollars out and then must give us the rest back", but that's what DRM does, to keep with pointless analogies.
- stcredzero 14y ago> This old argument? No, it's not. Congrats on being another knee-jerk reactor. > With digital goods, one master cracker does the work once Your analogy only fits the use of DRM by big companies. With a lock guarding long tail or personal data, there isn't one lock to be broken just once. There are millions of locks. Sure, a cracker can get Jane Doe's data and post it to the Internet, but someone could also break into her house and steal her grandmother's old brooch. In both cases, the damage is done and can't be undone. The point is -- is there enough economic incentive to make it happen all the time? No, there isn't. The value is too diffuse to normally attract intensive hacking. Instead of guarding something everyone on the Internet cares about, why not use the tech for guarding stuff only a few care about, in a context where the parties involved are largely trustworthy. There's still a need there, as evidenced by very weak physical locks used by small parties as deterrents to crimes of opportunity. > Also, with cash, you don't hand over the entire box to someone and say "you can only take a few dollars out and then must give us the rest back", but that's what DRM does, to keep with pointless analogies. You think you're being clever, but just have missed the point. In this case, it's more like the lock box at the local church Bingo. It's not much security, but it doesn't have to be. There is still value in being able to prevent crimes of opportunity and tremendous unacknowledged need.
- jessaustin 14y agoHow would this work? This proposal seems to assume that the situation of private individuals and their personal data is similar to that of big content companies and their content, except for a slightly different threat model. In fact the two situations are quite different. Jane Doe isn't publishing her credit card number and "protecting" it with DRM, as silly as that would be.
- stcredzero 14y ago> In fact the two situations are quite different. Yup. My point exactly. Congrats on being another careless knee-jerker who applies big-company context as a straw man and doesn't read carefully or think it through.
- jessaustin 14y agoYou're going to have to spell it out for us morons. How on Earth could DRM help the average person?
- jessaustin 14y ago[crickets]