3 ms·
Why should a man second-guess a god?
by philwelch 14y ago
Why should a man second-guess a god?
- chill1 14y agoBecause we can.
- darkchasma 14y agoWhose second guessing a god. I'm second guessing your absurd claims that there is a god. When said god shows up at my door, then I can second guess his inane actions, but until then, I'm simply second guessing the claim that any god exists at all.
- philwelch 14y agoI'm not making any claim that there are gods. I, too, am an atheist. I'm only making a conditional statement that if there are gods, it would not be the place of men to second-guess them. I wasn't commenting on the truth value of my statement's antecedent, just pointing out an inconsistency in rapala's reasoning.
- run4yourlives 14y agoIf a god exists and created us, not second guessing him with the brain he gave us is to deny his essence. Either it's exactly what we should be doing, god's a complete idiot, or he doesn't exist. Regardless, not much concerning ourselves with.
- rapala 14y agoBecause another god seems to be offering a better deal. I think that the point of the quote is that one should not care about the unjust good. Why would I want to be "welcomed" by a god that does not care about my pursuit of good life but only about devotion?