5 ms·
"You can have all the "Doubts on progress and technology" you want, but if you only count one kind of loss (electrical conversion) and not another (mechanical f
by bigiain 14y ago
"You can have all the "Doubts on progress and technology" you want, but if you only count one kind of loss (electrical conversion) and not another (mechanical friction and inelastic fraction) you're going to end up with a non-realistic bias in favor of mechanical systems every time."
I've been wondering for a while whether anyone's trying to re-capture some of the "lost" energy from household electrical systems. I wonder why my fridge, aircon, and stove aren't "pre heating" the cold water going into my hot water heater? I even wonder why all my "fixed electronics" - I'm looking at the TV, Playstation, audio gear, media center PC, home networking gear - have all got heatsinks and fans "disposing" of "waste heat" (which I sometimes then spend more money dealing with by cooling the room down with aircon).
Is there _really_ no good way to capture all that "waste heat" and use it to offset the energy I consume having a hot shower every day?
(I'm guessing I'm not the first to ever have these thoughts, and that the answer right now is "power is so cheap that the payback time for any available technology that could do this is way longer than practical". Which satisfies the pragmatist in me, but still makes the tree-hugger in me slightly melancholy.)
- marvin 14y agoThere is a very simple solution to this if you are in an area where electricity is cheap and the climate is cold. Simply use electrical heaters with a thermostat. Using electronic appliances, including light bulbs, increases the temperature and reduces the time your heaters have to run. This is also the reason why low-energy light bulbs are less profitable in certain countries.
- bigiain 14y agoYep. I've mostly go the other problem though. Here in Sydney Australia, it's reasonably rare for us to need to heat the house - especially right now, in the middle of our summer. Even in the middle of a Sydney winter it's uncommon for us to actively heat the house - we've only got one "space heater" in the house, a little 1000W fan heater that mostly gets used to dry rained-on motorcycle jackets/boots/gloves. Very rarey (perhaps 2 or 3 days per year) we run the aircon in reverse-cycle heating mode. I guess that your comment probably reveals another reason why this idea isn't currently economically feasible - the "richest market" where the pre-conditions for it to work (households with significant amounts of "waste heat generating electronics" running permanently or close to), is surely the USA and the 2nd richest market is probably western Europe. Both regions where for a large part of their population, the climate is cold enough for significant parts of the year for your simple solution to be "good enough". A market the size of Australia (~20million people) probably isn't anything like big enough to get the economy of scale to work. Now my tree-hugger side is even more melancholy...
- spearo77 14y agoMichael Mobbs has been at it for a while.. http://sustainablehouse.com.au http://sustainablehouse.com.au Check out "The Plan" for the larger scale objectives.
- emiliobumachar 14y agoI would think using electronic appliances would save heating effort on any closed-loop heating system, electrical or not. Am I missing something? Other than that, great point.
- schiffern 14y agoYour solution is penny wise and pound foolish. Using heat pumps will save you enormous amounts of energy overall, even though your appliances look superficially worst under that analysis. The economic equivalent would be: You: "Hey Bob, those are expensive fishing trips. Think of the opportunity cost!" Bob: "Thanks, you've saved me a bundle. I'll go quit my job immediately!" (The effect you're citing is real, but the explanation is more basic: at low energy costs, efficient goods have longer payoffs. This happens regardless of what heating method people use.)
- marvin 14y agoYes, this is very obviously true. But there are very good historical reasons why this is the way things have traditionally worked in Norway. First, heat pumps were very uncommon until only a few years ago, since no one needs A/C in this cold climate. A heat pump can have a 10-year payoff with our electricity costs, although this has gotten better in recent years. There is no gas infrastucture. And it makes no sense to switch to high-energy appliances untli you're switched to more efficient heating.
- schiffern 14y ago>I wonder why my fridge, aircon, and stove aren't "pre heating" the cold water going into my hot water heater? I asked the CEO of SunFrost (who make super-efficient fridges for solar houses) whether he had examined the possibility of a water-cooled refrigerator. He said that people didn't want to pay a plumber to install and remove their refrigerator, and that the lifetime savings doesn't really pay for the extra time and hardware.
- ajuc 14y agoIn cold climate waste heat from electronics isn't wasted. Also I think some old customs were really ecological just because of being used to scarce resources. For example - my grandpa have old ceramic stove for cooking in the kitchen. It has pipes with water inside - additionaly heating water for washing, when you cook. I've always thought it's a great idea. My grandma also had big plastic bucket in the tube in the bathroom, when you washed your hands during the day you did it over that bucket. When you needed to flush the toilet, you first used the water from that bucket, only if it was empty you used built-in "flusher". These things weren't really needed anymore, but that generation got used to not waste anything.