4 ms·
So when you reach a certain (unspecified) karma level, the quality of your submissions stops being judged by HN readers and starts being judged by HN admins? An
by smacktoward 14y ago
So when you reach a certain (unspecified) karma level, the quality of your submissions stops being judged by HN readers and starts being judged by HN admins? And in twenty-plus cases they consistently found my submissions wanting, every time? Wanting so much that they needed to be filtered out before other HN users could even see them?
If that sounds reasonable to you, you've found a friendly place here, I guess. To me it sounds bizarre.
Find something really good to submit from an obscure corner of the web. Not the usual suspects. Not linkbait. Not blogspam. Then you can test your theory.
My submissions included stuff I wrote myself, which is by definition "not the usual suspects."
Look at this piece, for instance, which I submitted:
http://jasonlefkowitz.net/2012/08/twitter-teaches-a-new-generation-of-developers-why-proprietary-platforms-suck/ http://jasonlefkowitz.net/2012/08/twitter-teaches-a-new-gene...
Is this blogspam? Is this linkbait? I would argue it's an original discussion of an issue that was much debated among HN readers at the time. You may agree or disagree with its premise, but I cannot see how you could classify it as cheap.
And yet it was killed, just like all the others.