4 ms·
It's transmitting power directly instead of taking it through a generator then back again using a motor, so it's quite possible. A quick search suggests that mo
by wlesieutre 14y ago
It's transmitting power directly instead of taking it through a generator then back again using a motor, so it's quite possible. A quick search suggests that motors and generators can both be over 90% efficient in the electrical/mechanical conversion, but I would guess that you could do better in a purely mechanical system.
Over short distances we already use mechanical energy transfer all the time (drive shaft in cars, chains in bikes, etc.), this takes the same idea and extends it to a longer distance.
My hunch is that while it would still work in theory, electrical systems would win out because of construction costs and maintenance. Motors and generators are widely available, wire gets laid once and works for decades, and contractors know how to deal with all of it. A jerker line needs more frequent lubrication, has custom parts that wear out, and when they do you can't just say "I need a new NEMA 6 motor" and have it in a day.
EDIT: Also worth noting that the high efficiency numbers for the electrical system are going to be at peak load, if you run it at partial they'll drop. The frictional losses on a jerker line are probably a bigger percent of the total at part load as well, but I don't know whether they'd be more or less significant than a generators'.
- wiml 14y agoIt's really easy to overestimate the efficiency of a mechanical system. Each of those swiveling joints, wheels, etc., is going to lose a few percent even if perfectly maintained. Some of the devices like the friction supports will lose more. Regarding replacement, I suspect that in an oilfield in the back of beyond in the late-19th/early-20th century, many of the replacement parts for these systems would be made on-site with a saw or a farrier's anvil.
- wlesieutre 14y agoIt might come down to whether you're using the oscillating motion directly or trying to turn it back into rotation. There's no way that you'd get rotation more efficiently than a motor, but elements like the tripod pendulums seem like they'd have comparably small losses to the generator/motor. Then again, I've never seen any measurements of energy losses on pushing a pendulum back and forth, so as you say, I could be overestimating the efficiency of those too.