3 ms·
Maybe we're talking about different fields, or maybe you misunderstood when I said "say, within 5 years of your PhD"? By this I mean that 5 years is the rough t
by jessriedel 14y ago
Maybe we're talking about different fields, or maybe you misunderstood when I said "say, within 5 years of your PhD"? By this I mean that 5 years is the rough time when citations become useful. Before that, when you're on your first or second post-doc, there just hasn't been enough time for a meaningful number to accumulate. Would you agree with my statement if I had said 3 or 4 years?
EDIT: Let me put it this way: suppose you're 4.5 years out of your PhD and you're applying for a tenure-track assistant professor position after two post-docs. Your competitor has 30% more citations than you, but in average journals, and last year you published in Nature; that article hasn't had time to rack up cites (which it will). Without knowing anything else about situation, who do you think is more likely to get the position?
- jpdoctor 14y ago> or maybe you misunderstood when I said "say, within 5 years of your PhD"? It sounds more like I misunderstood when you wrote "you haven't had time for citations to accumulate, and journal name really is the important thing." Your example above combines journal citations with place-of-publication, which makes more sense than one important item. And lets face it, there have been some real whoppers in Nature. Jan Hendrik Schön comes to mind. So to your example: I can think of only a single situation in which a last-year-item of any quality affected a decision. The likely answer to your question is that neither of the candidates would be hired, at least at the best institutions.
- jessriedel 14y agoI agree that my statement was muddied. Thanks for your thoughts.