3 ms·
It is shit like this that makes me what to shut down the FDA and ban anybody who has every worked there from having a job again. Isn't it enough that sick peop
by tomjen3 14y ago
It is shit like this that makes me what to shut down the FDA and ban anybody who has every worked there from having a job again.
Isn't it enough that sick people have to suffer from their sickness? Does these nazies have to destroy their only chance of a better life?
If it turns out that the cure doesn't work, then let the estate sue the company -- don't go around ruining peoples life just to increase your own power.
- geoffschmidt 14y agoThere's another side though. Do you want to see pseudoscience stem cell "therapies" sold on late night infomercials as a panacea? A balance has to be struck between the number of people that could potentially be helped and the number of people that could potentially be harmed. We can debate how this balance should be struck without assuming bad faith on the part of those that disagree with us. On the internet, when startups overpromise, misrepresent, and take risks, the worst that usually happens is that a few million people lose their data or get their embarrassing photos shared with their coworkers. In health care the consequences of an overhyped technology are far more grave.
- tomjen3 14y agoHow would you react if your father couldn't get the kind of treatment that he needed because the FDA wouldn't let him? If the supplier is lying, that is fraud (and can be prosecuted even after the fact); If they find out that it was a good deal after he has died, how does that benefit him?
- gus_massa 14y agoThey will say that it's not a fraud. It was only an experimental treatment fundamented in abstract "principles" and they had some signs that it improves some of the symptoms in a few patients. Regrettably all the new studies proved that it doesn't work but the risk were clear in the small letter of the contract. Luckily now they realized that this treatment can be possible useful for another illness and/or they have another experimental treatment for this illness.
- ataggart 14y ago>Do you want to see pseudoscience stem cell "therapies" sold on late night infomercials as a panacea? Mandatory FDA approval is orthogonal to over-the-counter sales. Surely you don't think the government should prohibit a medical decision between a patient and her doctor... > when startups overpromise, misrepresent, and take risks, the worst that usually happens... Yes, the risk people are willing to bear is proportional to the damage it can cause. This is probably why terminal patients are willing to risk experimental drugs.
- rdouble 14y agoDo you want to see pseudoscience stem cell"therapies" sold on late night infomercials as a panacea?" This already happens in Koreatown. http://la.curbed.com/archives/2010/11/beyond_boba_tea_koreatown_galleria_tenant_advertises_pet_cloning.php http://la.curbed.com/archives/2010/11/beyond_boba_tea_koreat...
- GiraffeNecktie 14y agoI don't see that shutting down the FDA is a good alternative. There are countless therapies that are dangerous and/or ineffective and plenty of unscrupulous or incompetent people who want to flog them. Yes there's a human cost to regulation, but that's nothing compared to the cost of opening the floodgates to every half-baked idea out there, not to mention the damage to medical science when the medical trials are bypassed.
- Gormo 14y ago> There are countless therapies that are dangerous and/or ineffective and plenty of unscrupulous or incompetent people who want to flog them. There are countless regulatory policies that are dangerous and/or ineffective and plenty of unscrupulous or incompetent politicians who want to flog them. So what process validates the "safety" and "effectiveness" of the FDA's universal-scope regulations? Certainly, given that you and I can't opt out of them as we can with drugs and medical procedures, the danger of bad policy can be far graver than the danger of bad medicine, yet there's no regulation of regulatory policy at all! I understand the desire to protect people from fraud and deceit, especially when the consequences of bad medicine are literally life-or-death, but surely the proper way to accomplish this end is to supply people with the data that will allow them to make informed decisions, rather than usurping their right make decisions in the first place. The FDA should function as a certification body, evaluating drugs and treatments, and informing patients as to the likely results of using each, but it should not have the power to prohibit anyone from undergoing any treatment or taking any drug.
- GiraffeNecktie 14y agoSounds good in theory but I don't think the average doctor, let alone the average patient, is capable of independently weighing the pros and cons of every novel treatment. And then you have desperately people who might normally be more skeptical but will believe just about anything in the pain and torment of a moment when they or a loved one falls ill. No thanks. I'll take the imperfect regulation over the "free market" any day.
- 14y ago