2 ms·
> Open access journals, based on authors paying $1,000-$3,000 to publish a paper, are going to be a temporary stepping stone on the way to the decline of the jo
by jessriedel 14y ago
> Open access journals, based on authors paying $1,000-$3,000 to publish a paper, are going to be a temporary stepping stone on the way to the decline of the journal.
At least in my field, papers cost roughly $50k-$100k for just the researcher salary and overhead. Paying $2k to get a paper published is not a high hurdle (especially once the norm of closed-access publishing fades away). And this really seems like the minimum cost that needs to be incurred in order to get decent copyediting and the editorial cost of co-ordinating the referees. I love the ArXiv, but if I can get a the copyedited version from the journal I will.
Yes the referees aren't paid, which may or may not change, but paying a PhD editor $500 to figure out the best referees and engage in the back-and-forth with them and the authors is pretty minimal. So $2k for a professionally edited, polished paper which is then free to everyone forever seems like a pretty good deal, and essentially a non-issue.
Your point about the need for incentives for scientists to share non-paper scientific output like code is well-taken (and well-known). But I don't see why this can't be solved by open-access journals. I am completely unconvinced that facebook likes controlled by a for-profit organization are the way to go.
EDIT: By the way, you've mentioned in several places the 12-month time lag for publishing. This was solved for the physics community by the ArXiv; the papers get immediately released, and you can still submit to journals for the benefits of copyediting and refereeing. (Afterwards the ArXiv version is updated.) I don't know of any reason it can't work for all of academia.
- RichardPrice 14y agoYou're right that the cost isn't the main issue. It shouldn't be disregarded though: with 2 million articles published a year, a $2,000 cost per article means $4 billion a year that could be spent on more research. To put that in context, the NIH's budget for tackling cancer is $4.9 billion a year. The main issues with the journal system are the effects it has on the speed and quality of scientific communication. Peer review by two people is not robust, and it is very slow; secondly, the full range of scientific media aren't shared. These are the problems that, I believe, require an overhaul of the reputation system in science. The only way to incentivize scientists to share their comments on papers quickly, and at scale, is to provide rewards for them to do that. The range of media that scientists will start to share will be shared on platforms designed for that media type. Code will be shared on Github. Videos will be shared on YouTube. Data-sets will be shared on sites like Figshare or other sites dedicated to handling that content format well.