4 ms·
> In fact, I know for a fact that if I had asserted the sort of stuff that you are asserting in a public space in my dorm when I was a student, that I would hav
by lutusp 14y ago
> In fact, I know for a fact that if I had asserted the sort of stuff that you are asserting in a public space in my dorm when I was a student, that I would have been showered for the offense.
And? The topic is science, not how youngsters punish behaviors they don't understand.
> In my experience, if you asserted that science did not aim for truth, most scientists would just roll their eyes and get back to work.
That's because scientists don't have time for philosophical debates about resolved issues.
> There's no one definition of science.
All definitions of science agree that falsifiability is a requirement. And science is now defined in law, to prevent people trying to squeeze into the world of science by claiming that it's not strictly defined.
> Credentials of course don't guarantee correctness. But they often provide a reason to trust someone's opinion, or at least to pay attention.
No, they don't. The greatest amount of scientific eminence is trumped by the smallest amount of scientific evidence.
"Science is the organized skepticism in the
reliability of expert opinion" — Richard Feynman
I saw no point in refuting all your incorrect arguments once by one. An education would have done this, but that's clearly lacking.
- nessus42 14y ago> That's because scientists don't have time for philosophical debates about resolved issues. How about I go poll about 20 working scientists tomorrow whether they seek truth or not, and get back to you? You know, real scientists, the kind who have PhD's (i.e., credentials) and get paid to make discoveries? > I saw no point in refuting all your incorrect arguments once by one. An education would have done this, but that's clearly lacking. Clearly. I'll go demand my money back.
- lutusp 14y ago> I'll go demand my money back. That won't work. MIT did their part, but as the old saying goes, you can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink. But since you haven't tried to defend your claim that science is a search for truth, let me do it for you. Let's say for the sake of argument that science is a search for truth. Science, in the modern sense, has existed for about 300 years, but it hasn't uncovered any truths yet. So why do people continue to support such a complete failure? If science was a machine meant to uncover truths, it would have been scrapped along ago. Prove me wrong. Identify a truth that science has uncovered. To save time, I'll propose an example -- evolution, a very well-supported scientific theory. Is evolution now true? Let's assume that it is. But if so, that means all the working evolutionary biologists are cheating their granting agencies and should be tried for fraud. Do you see where this is going? There are no truths in science, but that is not at all surprising, because truth is not the goal of science. This, by the way, is how I reply to religious fundamentalists who say that science is just a bunch of theories, and no final truths -- that is correct, and it is by design, not by accident. > You know, real scientists, the kind who have PhD's (i.e., credentials) ... Where do you get these ideas? Science is not about credentials, it is about evidence. Were this not so, Einstein, the un-degreed patent clerk, would not have been published in 1905. But as it happens, he was published. The reason? He sent his work to scientists like himself, people who care about substance.
- nessus42 14y ago> Where do you get these ideas? Science is not about credentials, it is about evidence. Is it your assertion that science is not at all about scientists? The vast majority of scientists have serious credentials, and, in fact virtually all job openings for scientists require these credentials. As for Einstein, he had a PhD at the time that four of his Annus Mirabilis papers were published, though it is not that uncommon for PhD students to also have papers published. In science fields these days, however, their professors would typically be coauthors, whether they actually had anything to do with the research or not. There are, of course exceptions. As for science not being about credentials, of course it is not about them. Credentials are just one of the many tools that are used for getting the job done. > Prove me wrong. Identify a truth that science has uncovered. It is oh so easy to prove you wrong! Here I go: In five seconds when I drop this pen, it will fall from my fingers to the ground. I can even accurately predict the velocity with which it will hit the ground, and the amount of heat that will be produced as a consequence. Here I go.... There I was correct. Science gave me a truth. There are millions more where that came from. As for evolution, yes evolution is true. Just because I can't prove something to a logical certainty does not make it not true. In fact, that's just Philosophy 101. Knowledge does not require provability; it only requires justified true belief. (There are some caveats with "justified true belief", but I'm sure that philosophers will have that worked out sometime in the next few millennia. In the meantime, that definition of knowledge works well enough for me and for all the scientists that I've chatted with about the subject.) As to there still being details to be worked out, that doesn't detract from trueness. If I have a clock and I say that it correctly tells the time within plus or minus one minute, if the clock does live up to that claim, then my theory that I can use it to measure time is true. With that theory, and my working clock, I will always know the time plus or minus one minute. None of this contradicts the fact that I might desire to own a clock that will tell me the correct time, plus or minus 30 seconds, or 10 seconds, or 10 milliseconds, or 10 microseconds. Better theories and better equipment allow me to produce more precise facts. Less precise facts are still facts. Edit: I will admit that one might typically not use the word "true" to describe a theory, which is a model, except for ones that we have extreme confidence in, such as gravity, QM, and evolution. If we do use the term "true" for theories of lesser confidence, then we are using the term "true" in the sense of a true compass rather than a true proposition. We might more typically use the term "accurate". But an accurate theory is "accurate" specifically because it produces true propositions with high reliability. Additionally, we can also rephrase any accurate theory to be a true proposition by stating it something like so: "We will be using a scientific model, which we will describe as follows: .... This model lets us make predictions with an accuracy given by the following statistics, and the following caveats: ....