3 ms·
> rather than rationally responding to my argument. There is no rational response to your argument. That's why I replied as I did. Philosophy isn't a science,
by lutusp 14y ago
> rather than rationally responding to my argument.
There is no rational response to your argument. That's why I replied as I did. Philosophy isn't a science, amenable to scientific debate and a conclusion based on evidence, which is why philosophical arguments have the character they do -- interminable and inconclusive.
> that science is a method for discovering facts about the external world.
Necessary but not sufficient. When a theory about observations is proposed and then tested, it is then that we cross the threshold of science. "Discovering facts about the external world" is not science, otherwise my saying "stars are little points in the night sky" would qualify as science. It doesn't, because no testable, falsifiable explanation is proposed.
My saying "I have a cure for the common cold -- I shake a dried gourd over the patient" is not science, both because it doesn't consider other explanations and because it doesn't propose an explanation. I have "discovered a fact about the external world" but what I have done is still not science.
Science is not "discovering facts about the external world". Science must include falsifiable explanations, explanations that are cast out if they fail subsequent tests.
> Arguing that via the scientific method we've arrived at a fairly good understanding of how humans evolved which is likely true in important parts is, in fact, quite the opposite of being a Creationist.
That's true only if we try to explain what we have observed, and accept the possibility of falsification of our explanations. Creationism and evolution don't differ as descriptions, they differ as explanations, and by the property that a falsification would destroy the nicest-sounding theory.
The above is what separates science and philosophy -- in science, concrete statements lead to concrete procedures for weeding out indefensible ideas.