3 ms·
Regarding your "If a person is accused of lying under oath, what's to stop him from lying more during the perjury trial?" - What's to stop an accused murderer f
by PeterisP 14y ago
Regarding your "If a person is accused of lying under oath, what's to stop him from lying more during the perjury trial?" - What's to stop an accused murderer from lying more during the murder trial? Does this prevent us from handling murder trials?
In a perjury trial, why do you need to ask anything at all? You have the documented testimony where the accused said X under oath, and you have the facts/evidence proving not X.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoYou need to ask, because that's what a trial is for. To give folks a chance to defend themselves; to allow mercy into the process. Its pretty common for Engineers to deconstruct social processes into algorithms, but the humanity often gets lost. Let me try: lying under oath happens during someone else's trial, when you're bound by law to tell the truth. During your perjury trial you're protected by the 5th amendment, so the process must by necessity involve information-gathering from external sources. Whether you lie or not then becomes almost immaterial.
- lutusp 14y ago> What's to stop an accused murderer from lying more during the murder trial? In that case, it would increase the roster of crimes the defendant is accused of. Not so for someone already accused of perjury. > In a perjury trial, why do you need to ask anything at all? In a perjury trial, the defendant's attorney might try to argue that the defendant didn't know what he said was false. Perjury requires knowing falsehoods, not inadvertent misstatements of fact. Or the attorney might try to argue that the falsehoods weren't material to the issues being tested in court. There are other defenses -- mental incompetence and others.