3 ms·
> Perjuring oneself while under deposition can lead to prosecution without any "miscarriage of justice" having taken place in the form of a concluded trial and
by lutusp 14y ago
> Perjuring oneself while under deposition can lead to prosecution without any "miscarriage of justice" having taken place in the form of a concluded trial and judgment based upon said testimony.
No, as far as I know and in most jurisdictions -- for it to be perjury, among the other conditions already listed, there must be a resulting miscarriage of justice. BTW IANAL.
EDIT: the "miscarriage of justice" issue often affects a prosecutor's decision to pursue a case, and it affects the sentencing phase, but it's not actually part of the formal definition. I was wrong.
> The courts might also consider context, where the fact of a member of law enforcement committing perjury might be considered particularly onerous ...
Yes, but that only applies to sentencing, not the issue of guilt. Whether the facts support a conviction of perjury is separate from the issue of an appropriate punishment after a conviction.
- pasbesoin 14y agoI guess I shouldn't conflate the courts with the prosecutor's office (and law enforcement itself, for that matter). And IANAL -- NEC (Not Even Close) -- myself. BTW, I hope that acronyms suffice in such disclaimers. ;-) The P.S. that I added to my grandparent, I wrote before you followed up. So, it was not in response to your response. Beginning to feel too much like a lawyer, just writing these convolutions... I appreciate your level-headed, and researched, responses. Admittedly, I'm going more than a bit on emotion, here. Without being overly versed in the details of the law, I watch the contemporary results and trends in this country with a growing horror. Of course, that may reflect my own particular circumstances [1] as much or more than an objective (however defined) measure of actual circumstances. -- [1] Including e.g. aging, competing with production environments that don't have to meet my own's level of expenses including due to regulatory and safety expenses, respect for IP, etc.