4 ms·
Harvard details suspensions in massive cheating scandal
- Symbol 14y agoI'm continually disappointed by the increasing disconnect of the lessons of college with the needs of our modern professional world. Nearly everything meaningful is done as a collaborate effort, yet in formalized education it is branded "cheating". Education is not a zero sum game (but grades often are).
- carbocation 14y agoCollaboration only makes sense when people have something to offer one another. It's actually valuable to learn something for yourself so that you can meaningfully contribute to collaborative efforts. Besides, ethics are important.
- andylei 14y ago> increasing disconnect of the lessons of college with the needs of our modern professional world. Nearly everything meaningful is done as a collaborate effort what's uniquely modern about collaboration? hasn't collaboration been important for hundreds of years?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jjoonathan 14y agoIt makes sense to allow collaboration in some contexts (homework) while forbidding it in other contexts (test taking). This way, students are rewarded for working together yet are still have an incentive to make sure they aren't simply letting their partners do the work at the expense of their own understanding (intentionally or not). The cheating happened in a testing context. Other parts of the class would have emphasized the collaborative aspect of learning, and I'm sure this contributed to the widespread consensus that sharing answers was OK, despite written instructions to the contrary.
- jeffdavis 14y agoDo you have specific suggestions, aside from not grading on a curve (which is common but certainly not universal)?
- yesimahuman 14y agoI agree. "Academic integrity" always seemed like a law that was enforced with strange brutality. I've never cheated on a test before, but I don't think working with others is a bad thing. In fact, I wonder if I was trained so much by this to only work on things by myself, which has other negative consequences.
- ehudla 14y agoExams are like job interviews, not like typical professional work. Do people typically interview collaboratively? No.
- xkcdfanboy 14y agoGiving a take-home test and then remanding students for working together is just silly. You don't wave your ice cream in front of the monkey cage if you want to keep it.
- WildUtah 14y agoThe course was "Government 1310: Introduction to Congress." Give the ones who cheated A's and flunk the rest.
- Zanyinj 14y agoI was unable to find which course it was this time. Although I suspect it was something along those lines again. There was a similar scandal in 2012 - here's my favorite commentary on that: http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2012/09/the_harvard_cheating_scandal_i.html http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2012/09/the_harvard_cheating_...
- doctorpangloss 14y agoIt's hard to not feel a little sympathy for the handful of 2012 grads whose lives were put on hold by the investigations this fall. A few months prior to the incidents, I had had a conversation with the College president and Dean Smith about cheating and mental health on campus. They were aware of some kinds of cheating; they were not aware of others, particularly the acute or technologically advanced kind. I argued to Hammonds, the College president, that the design of exams was the root cause of the cheating, not a lapse of morals. It seems that I was vindicated in this assessment, because cheating happens in classes with final exams of any kind, most strongly in take home exam classes. This is just a particularly egregious example. On the other hand, it could be that morally deficient students sort themselves into Government and Economics. But that's utterly ridiculous, and I hope most will agree with me that fixing the tests (preferably by eliminating them), rather than just blaming the students, is the right step forward.
- WalterBright 14y agoAn interesting counterpoint to this is the experience of Caltech, with its honor system (I attended Caltech). It is institute policy that exams are not proctored in any way. Exams are normally take-home. They are time limited, starting from when you open the test. Yet cheating is nearly non-existent. How is this possible? I think it is because the honor system is a pretty explicit statement that the Institute implicitly trusts its students. It views professors and students as collaborators, rather than adversaries. One consequence is that the students like the honor system very much, and do not wish to see it change. Hence, there is intense pressure from the students to themselves to not cheat - and someone who does cheat is pretty much ostracized. (There are other aspects to the Caltech honor system - professors are not allowed to take attendance or base grades on attendance in any way. The Institute also does not attempt to control student behavior on or off campus. I don't remember ever locking my dorm room door.)
- WalterBright 14y agoYou might ask how do I know that cheating was nearly non-existent? One, nobody is going to help you cheat. Two, I never knew of anyone who cheated. Three, some classes had more than half of the students fail the exam - hard to believe if there was widespread cheating. And four, I knew a not atypical student who fell asleep during an exam, woke up and finished it, but noted on the exam that he'd been awake for less than the time allotted, but his sleep time exceeded it. He received an apologetic F on it, and had to repeat the class next year. Nobody thought this self-reporting was unusual or particularly worthy of comment. It was just the way it was.
- DalekBaldwin 14y agoI see from your other posts that you attended Caltech in the '70s. You might be disappointed to read the more recent anecdata: http://www.quora.com/California-Institute-of-Technology/Why-are-some-core-classes-at-Caltech-administering-in-class-exams/answer/Donnie-Pinkston http://www.quora.com/California-Institute-of-Technology/Why-...
- WalterBright 14y ago
- gcatalfamo 14y agoI don't understand, Americans are still getting shocked that is in the students nature to try and cheat their way to graduation? Both parties are guilty, one of cheating and the other of being so naive.