8 ms·
> I don't see how you can dismiss the notion of truth and then invoke falsification. What does "false" mean but "not true"? I will let philosopher David Hume e
by lutusp 14y ago
> I don't see how you can dismiss the notion of truth and then invoke falsification. What does "false" mean but "not true"?
I will let philosopher David Hume explain it: "No amount of observations of white swans can allow the inference that all swans are white, but the observation of a single black swan is sufficient to refute that conclusion."
To summarize, we can never say that all swans are white (a truth) but we might be able to prove that claim false.
> What does "false" mean but "not true"?
The statement that an assertion is false follows different rules than the statement that an assertion is true. And a theory that's supported by evidence can always be proven false by new evidence -- the point being that no theory ever becomes true in perpetuity (except in mathematics). More detail here:
http://arachnoid.com/doubt http://arachnoid.com/doubt
- mjn 14y agoNothing in that explanation is incompatible with the view that science is a "search for truth", at least taken in a suitably weak sense that does not claim to have "found" it. Falsificationism is simply a methodology, not any kind of end goal. The whole point of following such a methodology is to come up with theories that are in some way "better"; the thing we actually want is the positive content of the theories, which can be used as models, make predictions, etc. If we weren't interested in the positive content of theories at all, there would be no point in trying to falsify them. That said, I think Popperian falsificationism is rather questionable as a philosophy of science, once you prod at it more than a little.
- lutusp 14y ago> Nothing in that explanation is incompatible with the view that science is a "search for truth". Of course it's incompatible. If there is no such thing as truth in science, that eliminates truth as a goal. And there is no such thing as truth in science. > Falsificationism is simply a methodology for finding where theories are non-truthy and amending them accordingly. No, this is not so. Falsification doesn't cut away those parts of theories that aren't representative of absolute truth, it cuts away the theories in their entirety. Astrology wasn't modified to become astronomy, instead astrology was demonstrated to be false and abandoned. The ether theory wasn't "amended" to become relativity, it was falsified in its entirety and abandoned. Falsifiability is not an editor's red pencil, it is a test against reality, and if the test fails, the idea is abandoned. > ... the whole point of falsifying theories is that we don't want false theories, but theories that are... less false. No. This isn't what falsifiability means. Falsifiability means that our ideas must be testable against reality, and only those ideas that survive the test remain standing ... to be tested again, later on, with new evidence. But we never declare a theory proven, beyond doubt (which would support your apparent notion about science).
- mjn 14y ago> Of course it's incompatible. If there is no such thing as truth in science, that eliminates truth as a goal. You're confusing epistemology and ontology here. There are things in the world which are physically true or false. That you cannot conclusively prove a particular proposition is true is an epistemological/methodological issue which is not incompatible with the existence of external reality, or the idea that the purpose of our methodologies is to more accurately model said external reality. And yes, one way we do that is by incrementally pruning theories; and another way we do it is by replacing entire theories. I've read Kuhn, so I don't have any conception of science as an incremental ratchet or anything. Put differently, there is an objective reality, and science is a method for investigating it. The fact that you can't declare victory, having arrived at a flawless transparent understanding of the objective reality, is not a good argument against either the existence, or the claim that the purpose of science is to attempt to model it. Without that basis science makes no sense in the first place, and you're at social constructivism.
- lutusp 14y agoEDIT: this thread, and the downvotes against this specific post, only demonstrate the futility of trying to debate with philosophers. For a philosopher, everything simultaneously is, and is not, science. For a scientist, Creationism is not science and doesn't belong in the classroom. Take your pick. ------------------------------------------------- > There are things in the world which are physically true or false. We're not discussing the world. We're discussing science. > Put differently, there is an objective reality, and science is a method for investigating it. (a) False as stated. (b) You skipped the part where we address the role of truth. > The fact that you can't declare victory ... Meaning discover absolute truth? That's not science's criterion for victory. > ... or the claim that the purpose of science is to attempt to model it [ "it" apparently meaning "arrive at a flawless transparent understanding of the objective reality" ]. That is not science's purpose. That's religion's purpose. Science has realistic goals, religion doesn't. > Without that basis science makes no sense in the first place ... Maybe not to you, but to a scientist, it makes perfect sense. This conversation reminds me why Richard Feynman disliked philosophers so much. Philosophical debates can produce anything except a working vaccine.