4 ms·
It would seem to me that a winning strategy would be to make these units, sell them, and ship them. In the delays for step 2 & 3, have them sitting around plug
by angersock 14y ago
It would seem to me that a winning strategy would be to make these units, sell them, and ship them.
In the delays for step 2 & 3, have them sitting around plugged in mining, paying for their use. The final sale defrays the cost of building the thing, and you effectively get free Bitcoins--right before the market for mining tanks due to your dispersal of mining ASICs.
Is this reasonable?
- DanBC 14y agoIf they build many machines, and use them all to mine at the same time, aren't they suddenly crashing the value? I guess if they get a good deal for energy (or need to heat the factory) "soak testing" is a good way to get a bit of money back.
- angersock 14y agoOh, they very much may be--but that's a problem for the purchaser. Presumably they've already been sold and spoken for, money having already changed hands. A slight delay of a few days in shipping--who's to say?
- imatworkyo 14y agocrashing the value of what? Bitcoin price is not tied to computational effort spent on mining. The creation rate of new Bitcoins is already constrained and well defined. Producing more machines would just mean Avalon would get a larger portion of the new Bitcoins.
- Nursie 14y agoCrashing the value of the machines? If they're that good and the manufacturers put a load online themselves, then the folks buying one are not buying as big a slice of the pie as they thought they could?
- DennisP 14y agoBut the amount of computation required to get a new bitcoin is definitely tied to the total computation being applied to mining.
- STRML 14y agoThat's the thing - this is not a traditional market but it is possible to 'crash' the difficulty. If enough of these things show up globally they can make mining so difficult for everyone else that they will have to give up. This is a very unhealthy thing for the BTC market in general as only a few players will have the ASICs to mine profitably, and everyone else will be spending far too much per kW to do any mining at all. One of the weaknesses of BTC, as far as I understand, is that anyone with a majority of the global hashing power can rewrite new transactions on the blockchain. If regular GPU miners give up and a few players spin up some massive ASICs, we may very well see this become a reality.
- STRML 14y agoIt seems strange to even sell these units at all right now. If they really can pay for their (retail!) value within a week, the real money is in running them, continuously, until the difficulty gets so high that they can only pay for themselves within, say, 6mo or more. It may be that the competition has driven manufacturers to attempt to sell so they can offload their stock. But Avalon claims that they are made-to-order. If it were me, I would've built 1000 of these, made them pay for themselves and then some, then started dumping as soon as it looked like a competitor was about to launch. And again, this sale is too early for that to make sense.
- AndrewDucker 14y agoThey cannot afford to make 1000 of them and keep them for themselves. They need the money up-front, and to get that they need to sell them in advance.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoYeah, this. They're crowdsourcing the funding for the NRE and associated costs of spinning an ASIC. They're also diversified a bit by being both miners, and shovel-merchants.
- STRML 14y agoThat must be it. The money is in keeping a significant portion of what they make for themselves, and using the sales to fund production of even more equipment, for themselves. Then, eventually, these things will be worth very little but the money will be made. I would imagine this will drive BTC prices pretty far downward. A few guys with a couple hundreds BTC mining ASICs can monopolize the vast majority of BTC being mined. And given the current price, they might want out soon.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoI'm starting to understand it a little better after studying it a bit. I don't think it will drive BTC "prices" down because there is a finite amount of the currency that is possible to be created. I don't think it can create a glut (I could be wring on that). There are a couple of incentives not to hoard all of the computing power. 1. Benevolent users want to avoid the "51%" attack. It could undermine confidence and perhaps cause users to flee. 2. It's possible that we'll see a hashing power arms race where several cycles of ASIC production supersede or render the previous generation unprofitable. While it may be possible to go it alone and win, it's still a risky prospect, for the above reason, and for the risk associated with ASIC development. Therefore, ASIC developers have an incentive to distribute the machines into the hands of BTC users at large, and quickly. These ASIC miners are going to have a limited profitability lifetime. While it may be years before they are uneconomical in terms of the cost of the electrical power to run them, they could be rendered barely profitable by a faster generation of ASIC based machines, or by an unfavorable turn in Bitcoin exchange rates; which could happen on a time scale of months or even weeks.
- spitfire 14y agoYou've just described how TV infomercials work. 1. Play the commercial on tv. 2. Sell the product and collect the money. 3. earn interest and find the cheapest manufacturer to do JIT manufacturing in the 6-8 weeks you have to ship the product. 4. Ship the actual product.
- mistercow 14y agoWow, that's actually a lot like Kickstarter.