4 ms·
tl;dr; Data is objective. But a decision process incorporates both data and a utility function (a goal [1]), and the utility function/goal is based on values.
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
tl;dr;
Data is objective. But a decision process incorporates both data and a utility function (a goal [1]), and the utility function/goal is based on values.
The successes that Bill Gates ascribes solely to data collection are actually due to a choice of utility function, together with using data to measure it and make decisions based on it.
However, the claim made in the title does not agree with the content of the article. Data is objective. Your choice of goals is the thing that is not.
Bill Gates chose as his goal (# of children who can read) - others prefer (# of teachers with lifetime job security) or (3 x # of children who can read + 2 x # of children who can do math). It is absolutely true that no amount of data will change your fundamental goals, and we should recognize this.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility
- lutusp 14y ago> Data is objective. Almost never true. One of the responsibilities of science is to gather data in a way meant to minimize sources of bias in the data collection process. Any number of studies have come to a very predictable, and wrong, conclusion, based on biases and errors in data collection. > It is absolutely true that no amount of data will change your fundamental goals, and we should recognize this. Yes, and one point of science is to separate the process of data collection from any particular goal or outlook.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoBias and error are not the same as a lack of objectivity. A loaded coin may come up heads 75% of the time. Using that coin to make a decision yields a biased procedure. It's also objective, since the bias is unrelated to the experimenter.
- lutusp 14y ago> Bias and error are not the same as a lack of objectivity. Say what? Bias is a lack of objectivity, that's how the word is defined. And errors can be managed by a combination of procedural discipline and peer review. In other words, the essentials of science. > A loaded coin may come up heads 75% of the time. Using that coin to make a decision yields a biased procedure. It's also objective, since the bias is unrelated to the experimenter. No, never. The outcome of the study is not objective if the experimenter believes the coin to be fair. And if the experimenter knows the coin is unfair, then it's not objective for a different reason. Objectivity is not a debating point as in post-modernism, it's a prerequisite for science, and with sufficient rigor, it can be established. This is not to argue that this is always true, but it is always possible.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- yummyfajitas 14y agoBias is a lack of objectivity, that's how the word is defined. No. According to a quick google search, "objectivity - judgment based on observable phenomena and uninfluenced by emotions or personal prejudices." There are many types of error, and they aren't all the same. a) Bias - an estimator's expected value differs from the estimatee's expected value. b) Inaccuracy - an estimator's variance is large. c) Lack of objectivity - the experimenter is applying incorrect methods for reasons other than lack of skill. The first two are properties of a statistical method, the third is a property of the statistician. All are orthogonal to each other.
- lutusp 14y ago>> Bias is a lack of objectivity, that's how the word is defined. > No. According to a quick google search, "objectivity - judgment based on observable phenomena and uninfluenced by emotions or personal prejudices." You just tried to deny the accuracy of a definition by quoting the definition of the word's antonym. Language doesn't work that way. > All are orthogonal to each other. Also false, and obviously so. In your list of points, (a) and (c) are identical, because "objective" means "a lack of bias". Source: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/objectivity http://www.thefreedictionary.com/objectivity Quote: "Objectivity ... lack of bias". Source: http://www.vocabulary.com/dictionary/objectivity http://www.vocabulary.com/dictionary/objectivity Quote: "Objectivity is a noun that means a lack of bias, judgment, or prejudice." And your point (b) confuses inaccuracy and variance, which are distinct factors. All your points (a through c) result in an easily definable and scalar error factor, not at all orthogonal.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoYou realize that "lack of bias" comes from the thesaurus, not the definition of the word, right? If you want to use an unusual definition of a word in order to make it apply to all errors (rather than only some), be my guest. There is no point disputing definitions. By your definition, you are correct, by the common definition, you are incorrect. http://lesswrong.com/lw/np/disputing_definitions/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/np/disputing_definitions/
- Lagged2Death 14y agoA loaded coin may come up heads 75% of the time. Using that coin to make a decision yields a biased procedure. It's also objective, since the bias is unrelated to the experimenter. That's just not true. The experimenter chose to record the results of coin tosses, chose the coin, chose the tossing method, and chose what variables to record (heads/tails for each toss). Before the coin is tossed the first time, human subjectivity and bias have already had ample opportunities to affect the outcome. What does it even mean to propose that the resulting data will be "objective?" The resulting bias, if any, is entirely the experimenter's responsibility. This is what the essayist means when she says "the people who own the model have the power." Her point isn't that using measurements is bad or that feedback loops can't work, it's that merely establishing an ambitious shiny new model doesn't offer any guarantee that the powers and influences that corrupted the old model won't corrupt the new one too.
- gruseom 14y agoData is objective. Your choice of goals is the thing that is not. These two are not independent. Your statement makes it sound like data grows on trees or falls from the sky. Of course that's not so. Someone chose to collect this data rather than some other data. That choice was not objectively given – it's very much affected by "choice of goals", as well as by pre-existing beliefs and no doubt countless other all-too-human factors. Moreover, the data may be wrong, but lutusp has that one covered.