14 ms·
Why Is Barrett Brown Facing 100 Years in Prison?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 14y ago> even though there technically isn’t one) is facing up to 100 years in jail for three separate indictments. The most recent two indictments—the threatening of an FBI officer in a YouTube video and the concealing of evidence—do not seem worthy of such a harsh sentence, considering a man in Houston recieved only 42 months for threatening to blow up an FBI building, and a former dentist got 18 months for threatening to kill an FBI agent. Interesting slight of hand comparing maximum possible jail time for three separate offenses to actual sentences for one.
- rosser 14y agoNot just three separate offenses, three separate indictments.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>Interesting slight of hand comparing maximum possible jail time for three separate offenses to actual sentences for one. I don't think cutting a century into thirds would do much to refute the disproportionality of the sentence to the underlying action. And the fact that the maximum and what the typical guilty party receives are so divergent is a big part of the problem. It leaves too much to the discretion of prosecutors and courts and is unacceptably coercive to the accused to have to risk anything like that sort of penalty merely in order to exercise any of the constitutional rights that effectively evaporate the moment you accept a plea bargain.
- rayiner 14y agoWe leave a large amount of sentencing discretion to judges on purpose, as a check against overreaching legislatures.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoThe issue is not that judges have the discretion to impose lower penalties in cases that warrant it, the issue is that their need to do so has become the rule rather than the exception. There are supposed to be checks and balances: Congress should enact a sensible maximum penalty so that it limits the scope of the damage when the judiciary makes a mistake, and judges have discretion to impose lower than the maximum penalties in specific cases to limit the scope of the damage when Congress makes a mistake. But Congress has abdicated their role. They've taken the judicial discretion that ought to have been a rarely needed relief valve and built the entire criminal justice system on top of it by imposing ludicrous maximum penalties and leaving it to the courts to sort it out. In consequence the check that Congress is supposed to be imposing on the courts effectively no longer exists, and if the courts get it wrong then there is nothing to stop it. Throw in that the plea bargaining system bypasses even the courts in the overwhelming majority of cases and you have the recipe for prosecutorial discretion becoming outcome determinative.
- rayiner 14y agoThe maximum sentence is not the target sentence. The target sentences are given by the federal sentencing guidelines. Judges have the discretion to give lower sentences in situations that warrant them, and have the discretion to go up to the maximums in situations that warrant them. But by and large they hew pretty closely to the sentencing guidelines. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Federal_Sentencing_Guidelines http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Federal_Sentencin...
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoI'm not sure how that addresses the issue of too much judicial latitude on the top end. Giving judges discretion to reduce a sentence makes good sense. Giving them discretion to go up (or equivalently to go anywhere which is "down" from the stars) is abdicating the duty of Congress and inviting injustice, and the uncertainty provides undue leverage to prosecutors in plea negotiations, especially for an accused with little experience with the justice system. And the uncertainty isn't just in the judge's adherence to the guidelines, it's in what goes into the calculation. The guidelines are obviously very complicated ("43 offense levels" etc.) and you don't get to present your case to a jury and learn their findings of fact before deciding to take a plea, so whenever there is a fact in dispute that causes an order of magnitude difference in the guideline sentence, the guidelines force the accused to take an unduly large risk in going to trial. Moreover, the sentencing guidelines are still full of harsh penalties. When Congress presents the authors of the guidelines with a maximum penalty of 25 years, it makes a five year prison term seem generous to the accused, notwithstanding that it is in actual fact an extremely harsh prison sentence in absolute terms. And, correct me if I'm wrong, whether something is a felony is based on the maximum penalty rather than the imposed penalty. So even if your actual sentence is "only" a number of months under the sentencing guidelines and in practice, you're still a felon for the rest of your life with all of the disqualifications that come with it if the maximum penalty exceeded a year. I don't think it's too much to ask for Congress to better differentiate between more and less serious crimes and to set appropriate maximum penalties for each.
- anigbrowl 14y agoWe've had this discussion before. The maximum sentence available under law is not a good guide to the maximum likely sentence. Think about the fact that murder can get the death penalty of life in prison with no parole, but the mean sentence is about 20 years and the median about 24 (from which you can infer that quite a few people get short sentences in the 6-10 year bracket). you can't talk about the disproportionality of the sentence because none has been handed down yet. It's meaningless to talk about the disproportionality of the maximum sentence when the law is designed to accommodate offences from the trivial to the truly egregious. You think this allows too much discretion to prosecutors and courts, OK, so did a lot of other people at one point, and that's how we wound up with standardized sentencing guidelines and mandatory minimums. Typical sentence lengths went up, because the sentencing guidelines are so exhaustive that prosecutors pile on obscure enhancements. Mandatory minimums were recently found to be unconstitutional, in US v. Booker. Federal sentencing guidelines were put in place in 1984. It's not a coincidence that the US incarceration rate took off for the stratosphere around the same time. Sentencing was more lenient, albeit less consistent, when it was left to the discretion of the courts. You don't lose any of your constitutional rights when you accept a plea bargain. The reality is that people take them because they don't expect to win in court. The standard of proof in criminal trials is very high, so defense lawyers have little incentive to accept a plea bargain unless the evidence overwhelmingly points to guilt.
- pzxc 14y agoYou don't lose any constitutional rights when you accept a plea bargain, but you voluntarily give up many constitutional rights. To suggest that the only reason people take plea bargains is because they don't expect to win in court is hardly reality. Many, many people take plea bargains because of the cost of a protracted legal battle, not to mention the stress. You're right on one thing though: we have had this discussion before. But if it was a clear-cut as you implicate, there would be no reason Aaron Swartz shouldn't have accepted a plea bargain.
- anigbrowl 14y agoHe should have. 6 months for a case where he was caught red-handed was a good deal. He would have been in a minimum security prison with white-collar criminals and possibly been a candidate for early release after 3-4 months. Forget about JSTOR; it's obviously against the law to secretly patch your computer into someone else's network wiring closet and repeatedly circumvent the security measures designed to keep you off the network. Something that has bothered me about the HN debate on this is that people think that because the MIT security response was weak and easily bypassed, there was no real offense in doing so. This is equivalent to saying that that only those with fortress-like security deserve legal protection from criminal access. Numerous people have objected that because the MIT wiring closet wasn't secure enough then there can't be anything wrong about plugging into it; essentially they're arguing that 'because I could' should be a valid legal defense.
- anigbrowl 14y agoAccuracy doesn't sell as much advertising as alarmism.
- rwmj 14y agoPresumably his lawyer will explain the true situation to him.
- logn 14y agoSo he's facing 100 years for releasing thousands of credit card numbers and security codes. He was leaking information and the numbers were not the motivation. Seems quite harsh, but am I missing something? Edit: He also appears to have just posted a link. Unless he actually uploaded the data, hopefully he's acquitted for that. By this standard, wouldn't Google be guilty of all sorts of terrible crimes?
- ryan-c 14y agoI read the indictment, and indeed, it appears that they charged him for sharing a link to a pastebin of credit card numbers from Stratfor customers on IRC. It's an absurd charge, and I hope it gets dropped. What he's in real hot water for is threatening a specific FBI agent, that agent's family and law enforcement in general. I also seem to recall reading that he posted something along the lines of "if any heavily armed people dressed as law enforcement show up at my home I'm going to shoot them because they're probably zetas dressed as cops".
- Zigurd 14y agoIt's a good bet many people reading this forum today downloaded and/or linked to leaked Stratfor, HBGary, and/or Britam dox. Do you think they should be charged for doing so?
- tzs 14y ago> He also appears to have just posted a link. Unless he actually uploaded the data, hopefully he's acquitted for that. By this standard, wouldn't Google be guilty of all sorts of terrible crimes? Intent matters in law.
- chasing 14y ago"Facing 100 years" != "will serve 100 years."
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThat's the problem. The only way to guarantee serving a reasonable amount of time instead of "he murdered his family and wore their skins to work" time is through plea bargaining, which perverts the justice system.
- mpyne 14y agoThe "maximum sentence" isn't even the recommended sentence that the accused would be having to plea bargain against, which is determined by the Federal sentencing guidelines. We went over all of this with Aaron's case, and yet people apparently still refuse to pay attention to how the U.S. legal system works, and instead continue to use MPAA/RIAA tactics when discussing these cases. I have to say it's certainly not very heartening to know that there is seemingly no ideology that won't use propaganda just as soon as it suits their cause. :(
- InclinedPlane 14y agoIs it in any way conceivable that the so-called "maximum sentence" could, speaking legally not about averages or practicalities, be applied in these cases? As far as I can tell, it is legally possible. And that's a big problem. Because it exposes the defendant to an exceptional amount of risk, regardless of their innocence or the facts of the case. It makes people much less likely to actually make use of their rights and to go to trial because no sane person is going to let even a tiny chance of going to prison for a century happen if they have a better out through plea bargaining. This case is a perfect example of that. If the defendant was facing a more reasonable maximum penalty such as, say, a year or two in prison he would likely be far more emboldened to take it to trial and have his day in court.
- mpyne 14y agoRisk is simply a probability, so it's inappropriate to treat a risk with a probability of approximately epsilon the same as a level of risk that could actually be seen on a pie chart. You're saying that because the risk of hitting the maximum sentence is not actually zero, that the defendant is exposed to an exceptional amount of risk, but this doesn't even make logical sense. Either way, whatever else defense attorneys might say to the prosecutors, judges, and the public, they know how the risks translate for their client even better than you or I do and have a professional responsibility to inform their client of the same. So there's no reason for a defendant to freak out about a theoretical maximum sentence, they should only be worried about the one the judge might actually assign after all the arguments and motions are made. > If the defendant was facing a more reasonable maximum penalty such as, say, a year or two in prison he would likely be far more emboldened to take it to trial and have his day in court. The maximum should be whatever is most effective for the interests of justice overall, not just whatever is most convenient for whoever happens to be sitting in the defendant's seat that day. I have a First Amendment right to say and speak my mind, but that doesn't mean I would go picketing funerals with hateful messages like WBC. I have a Second Amendment right to bear arms, but that doesn't mean I would stand near a school carrying a Bushmaster. And I would certainly never expect the government to provide me a Bushmaster and have me stand outside a school just to demonstrate that they care deeply about my rights. So yes, by all means, take your day in court if it comes to it, but it's not the government's job to ensure that is the only course available to you the defendant, it's the government's job to secure the blessings of liberty for all of the people.
- Strshps1MoreTim 14y agoWhy? Are you playing naive? Information today is the ultimate power, those surveillance systems are operated by the most powerful people in the world. A guy takes actions against them, how shocking he's getting punished.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- linuxhansl 14y agoFacing 100 years so that he'll waive his constitutional right to a trial (undoubtedly before jury entirely incompetent in the matter) and accept a mere 10 years in a plea bargain.
- anigbrowl 14y agoHe's not facing 100 years for god's sake.It's ironic seeing you complain about juries being incompetent when you're showing off such ignorance of the legal system.
- algorias 14y agoWell, please do share your insights with us. That's what this site is for, not ad-hominems.
- lmz 14y agoHe has in another comment on this submission: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5155342 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5155342
- wisty 14y agoI think it's been shown that jury trials typically have much larger penalties than plea bargains. It's like in a developing country, where you can bribe the policeman to "make it go away". The only difference seems to be, in the US the police don't benefit from the lack of process, and tax payers have to fund more prisons.
- linuxhansl 14y agoWell, please enlighten me then. If the possible penalty is 100 years he is facing a possible 100 years. Together with incompetent juries this becomes a high risk gamble.
- at-fates-hands 14y agoThat is if it gets to a jury trial. If he's smart, he'll plea bargain, give up some of his homies and take a ten year stint in a federal institution somewhere. If he can afford a decent attorney, he might even get a few charges dropped. Just as an FYI, the feds pile on indictments as a way to gain leverage. Since the federal government doesn't like hackers much, when they finally catch one, they're going to squeeze him until he gives up names or enough information to catch other Anons. Look what they were able to get out of Xavier Monsegur.
- nextparadigms 14y agoWhy does US have such a stupid system that seems to be abused to get people to accept plea bargains, which should be illegal in the first place, anyway? Is there any other country where they "stack" sentences on top of each other? Maximum sentence should be 20 or 25 years for 99.9% of criminals, and only the most cruel ones (mass murderers, etc) should get "life".
- bybjorn 14y agoHear, hear!
- OGinparadise 14y ago"considering a man in Houston recieved only 42 months for threatening to blow up an FBI building, and a former dentist got 18 months for threatening to kill an FBI agent" Nonsense! I bet those guys were also facing decades if not centuries of jail. What they got after the trial or a plea bargain is another story.
- serf 14y agomaybe Vice can go interview him , forget to sanitize the EXIF data, and somehow make things worse.
- mpyne 14y agoWell they linked to Barrett Brown stating that many of them (Anonymous) would not hesitate to employ the same amoral "might makes right" tactics that they deplore from the government, if they found it necessary: http://pastebin.com/WPE73rhy http://pastebin.com/WPE73rhy I guess he thinks "might makes right" is OK as long as the dictator is benevolent enough?
- trotsky 14y agoI'm not disputing that what he's charged with (nothing that whitehats and journos don't do all the time) doesn't suck, or that potential maximum sentences in computer crime aren't oddly out of whack at times. But lets cut the crap - Barret was a target because he dedicated a considerable amount of his time to being the mouth piece of some of the more radicalized groups inside anonymous, who went out of their way to directly antagonize the US government over and over, the more public the better. If you're going to ask as a spokesman for an ongoing criminal enterprise that are making fools out of law enforcment you'd better hope to hell they get caught before too long. Because you will always represent a decent 2nd place trophy for them if push comes to shove. I'm not saying it's right, it's just realism. It's nothing that wouldn't go down the same way (or much worse) in a vast majority of nations. It's like rolling your cat in bacon grease and sending it out to play with the mountain lions. No doubt you loved your pet and it's sad that it died. And maybe you're dumb enough that you didn't realize how stupid that was in advance. But you can't really blame the mountain lions, it's just their nature.
- pstuart 14y agoCriminal enterprise or civil disobedience? Does "anonymous" exist for profit or to effect change?
- trotsky 14y agonot the best choice of words i agree. They do at times bear some similarities with what I might call "freedom fighters" - but that is also usually true of people that the US labels terrorists.
- andrewcooke 14y agoyou're not saying it's right, but you accept it. so aren't you part of the problem? corruption shouldn't be the norm. justice should be blind, not vengeful.
- trotsky 14y agoYou're right that I'm not an active part of the solution, here. If you have the energy to actively campaign against every injustice you know of in this world or anything even close then I honestly thank you for working so hard for the public. From where I sit though, most of the world appears corrupt and injust to varying degrees, many far worse than what's going down here. So I pick other fights. And while I have no illusion that I'm somehow being of any real help here, i think it is fair to say that pointing out that it is extremely unsafe to play in traffic is a reasonable approach to reducing the number of people who will get hit by a bus.
- tzs 14y agoHe's not facing 100 years. To get the maximum sentence for a Federal crime, you have to (1) be the Hitler or Moriarty of that type of crime, and (2) have an extensive prior criminal record.