2 ms·
> So, next time you write something, make sure you submit to Hacker News, even if you don't get upvotes, people will still read it. Sorry, I have to disagree.
by danso 14y ago
> So, next time you write something, make sure you submit to Hacker News, even if you don't get upvotes, people will still read it.
Sorry, I have to disagree. It is not "awesome" to get pageviews for the sake of getting pageviews. What is awesome is if 1 out of those 100 people who gave you the benefit of the doubt gives you an upvote because you gave them something interesting to read.
Instead of "Still awesome to submit", it should be "Still awesome to write/create". Don't tie the point of your writing to some nominal number of random readers.
- mapgrep 14y agoYou're putting words in OP's mouth he never said. He wrote these articles because he thought they'd be useful, submitted them to HN, and was happy to learn later that, even with zero upvotes, they'd been read by dozens of people. He explains this in the second sentence (!) of the post: "I try to write some useful info like How to land an airplane if you are not a pilot or This is why you should never use Oracle DB those are not very interesting topics but, anyway, I always submit my post to Hacker News hoping at least 10 individuals would read it." There's a world of difference between writing something to get attention versus writing something you truly believe and being heartened when it gets attention. He never suggests people should engage in the former, he just says to submit to HN when you do the latter.
- danso 14y agoI didn't put words in the OP's mouth, I used a direct quote, and I don't think I took it out of context. > So, next time you write something, make sure you submit to Hacker News, even if you don't get upvotes, people will still read it. "something" not "something worthwhile" or "something you care about". Is it a far stretch to think that OP is saying, "Who cares if no one actually affirms your work, at least you'll get pageviews?" And while that's probably a true statement, I think it's not overall a net positive for HN. I'll give the benefit of the doubt to the OP that what he actually means is: "Even if you don't get any upvotes, your content will still get read, and at least a few people will benefit from it" But I can't, as you say, put words in the OP's mouth.
- scotch_drinker 14y agoImplicit in that "something" is at the very least "something you care about" because frankly, while the Internet is filled with a bunch of crap, usually the producers of said crap actually do care about it. It's hard to sit down and write 5 paragraphs about something you don't care about.
- tgrass 14y agoYes, it is a stretch to assume the OP meant "Who cares if no one actually affirms your work, at least you'll get pageviews?" His writing did not exclude that interpretation, but it didn't include it specifically either. We shouldn't be grabbing any possible interpretation from our own perspective and projecting it onto the OP.
- nicholasjarnold 14y agoI haven't submitted stories personally, but I think I understand what he meant: Even though nobody took the time to come back to HN and exalt him with karma, the page views he received meant that somebody 'out there' experienced his creation. The desire to be part of a group and share one's ideas with others is a pretty common trait shared by most human beings. Therefore, even if nobody thinks what he said is awesome enough to elicit an upvote, at least he was able to share it with the world. It's a validation that the work didn't just end up in the ether. I would argue that it's Not Awesome to only write/create. Instead, it's awesome to be able to get one's writings/creations in front of others. We all have an ego...even if we don't admit it.