2 ms·
I don't know, the effectiveness of torture as an interrogation tool is for understandable reasons difficult to assess. Not so. It is remarkably easy to assess
by btilly 14y ago
I don't know, the effectiveness of torture as an interrogation tool is for understandable reasons difficult to assess.
Not so. It is remarkably easy to assess, and everyone who cares to know already knows the answer.
After you break under torture, the victim will tell the torturer anything they think the torturer wants to hear, and has very little sense of what is or is not true. "Beating" torture is simple - pretend break early and tell interesting lies. When you really break you'll no longer know truth from fiction - nor can a questioner who has no idea which leads are true and false. Once you've hit that point then absolutely no method of getting information can work.
We have much, much more reliable interrogation techniques. Ones that we can use without giving propaganda benefits to our enemies. Admittedly no other technique gives the same visceral satisfaction of making someone pay. But once you've gone the torture route, you can't undo that choice.