3 ms·
'a tribalism which casts so many as as unthinking malevolent "others."' I'm actually not worried about people cackling about how they can finally enslave the m
by jerf 14y ago
'a tribalism which casts so many as as unthinking malevolent "others."'
I'm actually not worried about people cackling about how they can finally enslave the masses. Generally they do such a bad job when that is a primary goal that they end up failing. (Remember DivX, the time-limited DVDs, for instance?) I'm worried about people incrementally making a small choice here and a small choice there and before you know it, we've still pretty much ended up in the same place. Yes, FOSS as a community has done a lot of stuff but it worries me to see so many people declaring the job done and that we don't have to worry any more. Using the FOSS community as the freedom backstop doesn't work if the FOSS community no longer thinks it has to worry about freedom because of past successes.
- brudgers 14y agoI don't think the job is done. I don't think it can be - FOSS is a tool which for some problems can remain in the box without lessening the benefits which come when a particular problem is solved. The problem of appliances locked down with spyware is an example. I believe it is a problem whose first order implications are more serious than those which FOSS (and even GNUism) are intended to address. The implications include threats to physical safety and political liberty. I understand that there are different opinions. I acknowledge that it might be the case that the best possible solution adheres to GNUist principles. I just think that an unwavering GNUist approach is likely to an impediment to achieving a good and practical solution I use "GNUist" because FOSS doesn't prevent lockdown - and "Stallmanist" sounds too much like "Stalinist". And like "pragmaticism" is too ugly to be co-opted for other purposes. My Symbian Phone would load open source code written in Java, but only after it was signed. I was granted the means of self-signing, but only by Nokia's grace. And that turtle goes all the way down. The OS could have been FOSS and the device still constructed so as to require code signing for the OS.