4 ms·
So this seems like a pretty enormous task. Having written a couple of compiler code generation phases, I must admit that this challenge is very attractive. Ho
by wglb 14y ago
So this seems like a pretty enormous task. Having written a couple of compiler code generation phases, I must admit that this challenge is very attractive.
However, there is something a little off about this proposal. First, the size of this effort is really quite substantial, even neglecting optimization. Secondly, the phrase The C++ Grandmaster Certification began
development as an internal training program, and the foundation was founded to offer it publicly suggests some compiler-writing company heavily involved in the C++ space. How many of those are there really? I mean, it has been 20 years since anyone made any money producing C++ compilers. All for-profit companies do it as a side effect. VC++, for example, in the 90s had 50 people working on just the compiler itself, not counting the Visual part.
So it presents a secondary challenge, which is 1) is this a real company 2) what really is the end goal?
Edit: Also, the bootstrapping question is not well addressed. What do we have to start with? Regular C? can I do the first phase in Lisp or Arc or Factor?
Am I allowed to look at other source, like that of g++ or clang or llvm or objective C?
Finally, the apparent copyright terms seem at least unacceptable, if not downright goofy.
- ethereal 14y agoRegarding the company in question -- my own best guess would be one that does static code analysis -- Coverity [0] comes to mind, for example. I can't really think of any other companies that would benefit greatly from having a large stock of employees that all know the C++ standard intimately. Except of course for those that write compilers, but as you say, there aren't many of those around. [0] http://www.coverity.com/ http://www.coverity.com/
- wglb 14y agoAh, a good possibility. I can't find it now, but they published a paper that said "There is no such thing as C" in which they discuss the widely varying implementations and expectations of C, different enough that special flags had to be invented on their tool to get weird programs to pass.