4 ms·
Or someone got the report a few hours early, didn't want to be seen to jump the gun (insider trading, and all that) and kicked off a new trading strategy 400ms
by smcl 14y ago
Or someone got the report a few hours early, didn't want to be seen to jump the gun (insider trading, and all that) and kicked off a new trading strategy 400ms earlier than they intended...
- rikacomet 14y agoand of course that also is only possible, when they know the exact time of when the news would go out. So that, they can time their activity just milliseconds before that, using tech.
- smcl 14y agoWell it seems to be known that the report is due for 10.30am, so it is possible. Just an additional possibility, though nanex are far more experienced in explaining odd activity in the markets than I am :)
- rikacomet 14y agoyes, I saw that, but think it in this way, that its a very unreasonable way, to give the time in advance. Its better for investers to have some luck with this, if the time is not given in advance, just the day roughly. The news will drop at any time during the 12 hours before or after the given day. This would cut the advantage those hardwired trading machines have, that do tons of trades in few seconds or even milliseconds. This should be one of the reforms against such things, in the interest of common folk investors.
- svachalek 14y agoIf your idea of investing involves reacting to news and trading stocks/bonds/commodities/derivatives on internationally automated markets then just donate all your money to a good cause because at least then you'll get a tax deduction out of it.
- tazzy531 14y agoFor a lot of these economic numbers and earnings report, they are provided to news organizations prior to the announcement with instructions that the information cannot be released prior to a certain time. So, for this example, that time was 10:30AM. The moment it hits that time, the reports get pushed out into the newswires and reported on-air. This allows the reporters to digest the numbers and figure out how to report it.
- analog 14y agoSo news organizations get this financially sensitive information before traders? Seems an almost too obvious way to make a quick buck.
- javert 14y agoOutsider here, but I can't think of a good reason to give this info to news people before traders, and as the parent said, there are obvious bad reasons.
- tazzy531 14y agoMuch of the news ia a facade. Reporters often get things like economic numbers and speeches prior to the event. Things like the State of the Union Address and candidate speeches are usually provided to the press beforehand so that they can package together a story. Next time you watch a major political speech, listen to the pundits prior to the speech. They will talk about all the things that the candidates are about to say. With regards to economic numbers, there's very good reasons for them to do it this way (pre-released to media and embargoed). If it is not pre-released, reporters will need to take time to report the numbers which gives certain people an advantage. For example, if you're monitoring Bloomberg for the CPI and the reporter is a slow typer, a person monitoring Reuters would have an advantage over you. Secondly, this forces a situation where reporters are in a hurry to get the numbers out which could potentially lead to errors. With these types of numbers, an error could have impact of billions of dollars in trades.
- ig1 14y ago
- madaxe 14y agoYeah. This. Just posted the same, didn't see yours. It's a classic straddle, going by the quick buy by the same points to the midway.
- roc 14y agoWhich begs the question of whether it was accidentally early. It may well be that the 'early' trader knew they weren't the only one with early access to the data and intentionally set their trades to be a tiny bit early, to increase their chances of getting out ahead of the people who schedule their trades for just-after the scheduled announcement. Which may well indicate a larger problem than one guy with a tip.
- dice 14y agoCouldn't it also just be clock skew on a host or local datacenter which set off a chain reaction? I mean, I know that traders are probably pretty anal about accurate clocks, but mistakes do happen.
- roc 14y ago> "mistakes do happen." Absolutely. I'm just saying there isn't much justification to assume it was a mere mistake. Particularly given the trades that show up just after the report was released, but before a person could conceivably process them and initiate the relevant strategy. That alone suggests gamesmanship, even if the "early" trader went earlier than he meant to.
- dlitz 14y ago> Particularly given the trades that show up just after the report was released, but before a person could conceivably process them and initiate the relevant strategy. Couldn't they be trading based on some natural language processing algorithm?
- roc 14y agoCould be. Are those sufficiently advanced that anyone would be confident-enough to wager amounts, based on their results, of the order at issue here?
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoOr they had an algorithm that was cocked and ready for the data release, engineered for maximum speed at the cost of fail-safes, which had its moment of premature excitement.