5 ms·
It's just another example of the "magical natives, so in tune with the natural world" bullshit myth.
by jff 14y ago
It's just another example of the "magical natives, so in tune with the natural world" bullshit myth.
- inyourtenement 14y agoI was about to respond to the GP with "Jared Diamond uses New Guineans in many of his examples because he spends an extraordinary amount of time with them. He's not trying to say they are unique." But you're right, he's a native fetishist.
- gshubert17 14y agoI read it as an example of natural selection. The natives who attune themselves to a particular risk, are much less like to die, and more likely to pass along, this particular idea.
- abraininavat 14y agoOr.. humans in general have evolved the ability to gauge risk and modify their behavior accordingly, long before any humans stepped foot in Papua New Guinea. That this particular culture is more vigilant than others (if in fact that's the case, which I highly doubt) has nothing to do with natural selection. It has to do with culture.
- pekk 14y agoOr maybe it's just where the author happened to learn this. He could have cited the boy scouts if he'd learned it there.
- Angostura 14y agoNo it's simply an example of people who live in a particular environment being well aware of the risks associated with it. For example, before I worked in the Peruvian rain forest I would not have guessed that being hit by a brazil nut was one of the commonest reasons for accidental fatalities in the forest.
- andrewflnr 14y agoGood grief, do you have to wear a helmet any time you're in the forest?
- Angostura 14y agoNo, but the rule of thumb was never to go into the forest when there was a storm with decent winds.