6 ms·
Fuck this shit. We need to have sympathy. Not because we've diagnosed someone with a disease, but because they're a person. Rates of depression are skyrocketi
by jdietrich 14y ago
Fuck this shit.
We need to have sympathy. Not because we've diagnosed someone with a disease, but because they're a person.
Rates of depression are skyrocketing all over the developed world and whatever we're doing clearly isn't working. Personally, I think the most obvious issue is that a group of intelligent people have simply accepted the notion that what's relevant isn't someone's life circumstances, but some vague and baseless notion of "abnormal brain chemistry".
The idea of depression is a miserable cop-out, it's simply victim-blaming. We say that there is something wrong with their brains, rather than saying that there is something wrong with society. If someone is unhappy, we need to support them. It is a dismal failure of our humanity if we require the justification of medical necessity to show basic compassion.
Swartz had obvious reasons to be miserable and obvious reasons to want to kill himself. We failed him, we fucked up. He didn't die of a disease, he killed himself because he quite justifiably felt that the circumstances of his life were intolerable. We didn't do enough as a community to support him and protect him. He was a young and vulnerable man, bearing the wrath of a spiteful government. It's shameful for us to even consider for a moment that there might be something wrong with Swartz's brain, when our failures to care for him are so obvious.
If we need a scientific explanation for why we should care about each other, that's our problem. If we require a doctor's say-so to provide support for someone in difficulty, that's our disease.
- Osmium 14y ago> Personally, I think the most obvious issue is that a group of intelligent people have simply accepted the notion that what's relevant isn't someone's life circumstances, but some vague and baseless notion of "abnormal brain chemistry". How about people who lead objectively wonderful lives, with good jobs and happy families, but still suffer from deep depression? The problem, if any, seems to be the other way round: that some people think only people will "bad" lives can suffer from depression, and everyone else should just "get over it." That's what seems wrong to me--and if identifying "abnormal brain chemistry" as a cause of depression helps people realise that anyone can be a victim then so be it. Clearly if someone is suffering then external factors can make it so much worse, but that doesn't mean depression needs an external cause. Sometimes it just is.
- cnlwsu 14y agoMaybe good job and family isn't the only factors in leading a happy life? Not that I agree fully that brain chemistry isn't a factor. That said, the fact that wealthier countries have higher depression rates (according to WHO) does make me think there is something non-biological involved.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoSpeaking from both experience and anthropological theory, I would hypothesize that wealthier countries have more depression because they are more mobile. To start with the anthropological theory, let's take David Graeber's notion from Debt about the trauma of slavery. It's not merely being made to work by force that makes a slave. On a personal level, what traumatizes and dehumanizes a slave is that they have been ripped from their context. Everything that tied the free person to their family, their friends, their tribe/nation, their home, their religion, their culture, even their enemies, it has all been taken away. I think whenever you take someone entirely out of their context and put them in an entirely new context, there is a chance for depression, because I think that on a deep level, depression is a phenomenon of a person being out-of-context, or at least, out of any context that can physically and mentally nourish them in the right way.
- jdietrich 14y agoAgain, this is part of the problem. Your argument presupposes that a good job and a happy family would be enough for anyone, that anyone who is unhappy with that life is medically abnormal. Just because someone is superficially content does not mean that their unhappiness is inexplicable. Describing a lifestyle as "objectively wonderful" is patently absurd, based as it is on the belief that it is possible to objectively judge what sort of lifestyle would make someone else happy. The neurochemical hypothesis is incredibly dangerous, because popular perception has drifted so far from scientific consensus. It is an incredibly weak hypothesis with only the scantiest of evidence, but is accepted as solidly proven by a great many lay people - some people in this comments thread describe it as "scientific fact". Most neuropsychiatrists and psychopharmacologists will freely admit that there is no real understanding of what depression is, let alone what causes it. Many laypeople perceive depression as a simple chemical deficiency, much like a vitamin deficiency - give someone vitamin C and their scurvy goes away, give them SSRIs and their depression goes away. In fact, SSRIs are only marginally better than placebo and have no statistically-significant effect in the majority of patients. This belief is a strong disincentive to seek out psychosocial interventions, which are at least as effective.
- pge 14y agoI appreciate where you are coming from, but I think it is wrong to dismiss the chemistry component. Having had close family members diagnosed with depression (and having lost a friend to suicide), I found myself amazed at the degree to which chemicals in the body do play a role. I have seen two cases of dramatic behavior changes in people who had no change in external life experiences (and extraordinarily happy life circumstances at that with strong and deeply caring support networks), and medication immediately corrected the behavior changes. I do not mean to discount your primary point - I agree that we all need to take care of each other, but all the caring in the world cant change brain chemistry, and sometimes that really is where the problem is.
- chongli 14y agoIf it's only chemistry, why is it so much more of a problem in the developed world? Is there an unstated implication of a potential environmental cause?
- onli 14y agoIt could be statistics - maybe people with depression in the undeveloped world simply die without having the depression diagnosed. But to my knowledge the current(?) model of depression says it is both. There is the clinical depression without noticeable external factors, and there are those depressions which are quite obvious a reaction to an unbearable situation. The clinical depression can manifest itself again and again and will most likely never vanish completely. The situational depression normally goes away if the situation changes - but sure those people need help to achieve that. Of course, that leads to the conclusion that both causes shouldn't mix, and it doesn't mean there can be no factors like genetically predetermined likelihood for situational depression. To the first commenter: Saying that it is brain chemistry does not mean we shouldn't help those people. It is the other way around: In saying "this is a serious illness", we make it impossible to say that the depressed is responsible, why didn't he simply change his life? No one can do anything against his brain, apart from medication and maybe - and that is a big maybe - psychiatric help.
- 14y ago
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 14y agoThere are bell curves of pretty much every human characteristic. When someone is at the far end of the bell curve in a way that negatively effects their interaction with the majority of humans that are in the bulk of the bell curve, we call it a disease. In the case of depression, deviations from the norm in that characteristic have a chemical basis. It's not victim blaming to point this out. That doesn't mean we don't need to be sensitive to people with circumstances that deviate from the norm. At the same time, our expectations of how we should treat people are calibrated to the typical responses of people in the bulk of that bell curve. It is regrettable but not necessarily wrong when those expectations conflict with the needs of someone who lies outside that region of normalcy. We owe everyone common decency, but we don't necessarily owe anyone uncommon decency.
- haberman 14y agoThis is well-put. What I often wish is that there was a different word for these "end of the bell curve" problems; lumping them together with diseases caused by actual pathogens is, I feel, what can cause some of the skepticism about them being "real," because they are clearly not real in the same way that HIV is. Having a clear classification would acknowledge that we know there's a difference, but that we still regard non-infectious disorders as very serious because they can be equally awful in their own ways, and they can sometimes respond to medical treatment.
- AlexandrB 14y agoThis was posted in a HN comment not too long ago. It's a very good lecture that goes into both the biological and psychological aspects of depression and then manages to tie them together. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc > We say that there is something wrong with their brains, rather than saying that there is something wrong with society. The real answer is probably a little bit from column A and a little bit from column B.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoI agree 99.9%, but just wanted to add one little thing. Depression is not only a matter of society or brain chemistry. It's personal circumstances, too. About 1.25 years ago, I had a depressive breakdown that resulted in my leaving my job. Luckily, I came from a family that had always been very supportive and understanding, and through various means got treatment and changed my life to put myself back on a healthier, happier path. But... it's still a little scarring today, on the emotional front. I know that I'm fighting a defensive battle if I put myself in certain living situations. Thing is, I was in a situation where many people would have thrived and been happy, not become depressed. It wasn't my brain chemistry, and it certainly wasn't a permanent illness. It was partially society, but most people would merely have been unhappy due to those societal factors, not depressed. It was social factors plus my burned-out personal state when it started (that I hadn't really recognized as still-burned-out) plus the social isolation I had put myself into by moving away from home and from my college town with nothing to ground me but a job plus the psychic pain of betraying several of my more important values and dreams. Part of the problem with depression, though, is that it reduces your ability to think. I can introspect on what was going with me far better now than I could then.
- npsimons 14y agoVery spot on, on many points, however: there are demonstrable links between brain chemistry, genetics and depression. Hell, I inherit depression from both sides of my family, and drugs have helped me in the past. That being said, I'm very averse to medicating a problem that can be solved otherwise, and I agree that treating the causes rather than the symptoms is much more fruitful. My depression is in remission, but it's been a long hard road, and I still have a ways to go. Keeping busy in technical forums helps :)
- KirinDave 14y ago> but some vague and baseless notion of "abnormal brain chemistry". Neurologists disagree. So science says you're wrong. > Swartz had obvious reasons to be miserable and obvious reasons to want to kill himself. We failed him, we fucked up. Just because society has failed someone doesn't mean they also didn't have problems.
- ahoyhere 14y agoI think most people who knew Aaron (even briefly, like me) sensed that he had some kind of emotional problem before any of this ever happened. I knew him in the Infogami days, pre-Reddit, and I ceased our friendship because of his negativity. He wasn't mean, but my main impression of him was "Smart… but negative." Cory Doctorow wrote about the harsh experience of Aaron's mentors, who were on the receiving end of his disappointment. Yes, the whole prosecutorial situation was adverse. Yes, it was ridiculous. Yes, he could have accepted a 6 month plea bargain… he did things which are if not outright illegal, clearly were not really aboveboard, either. Yes, I believe that a lot of what people call 'depression' has to do with circumstances[1] -- and you'd have to have been a lot closer to Aaron than me to know if there were circumstances making him miserable back then, or if it was an organic issue, or simply who he was, personality-wise. Many people in worse situations don't kill themselves. Many people in lesser situations do. None of that matters. The fact that Aaron took his own life is tragic. I was truly sorry to hear it, but… I wasn't very surprised. It's simply a fact that things are more complex than they appear from the outside. People are more complex than they appear from the outside. And when you spend a lot of time with someone, sometimes you say "Oh, they're depressed," when really they have a lot of shitty people in their lives; and sometimes it's because they make choices that make their lives miserable; and sometimes it's because they have a real organic issue that has nothing to do with their daily lives or friends/family/job or personal choices. You can't know, though, from the outside. Only they can know. That's the fact of the matter. None of this downplays the need for empathy. I think it increases it. But there's no point in saying "depression is chemical" or "depression is because of shitty circumstances" or "depression is a fault of choices." Unless it's you -- and probably even if it IS you -- you can't ever know which it is. [1] NOT saying this is to do with Aaron, but just based on my experience of a lot of different people and reading a lot of research -- "circumstances" can include all the obvious external things we think of as circumstances, and also personal, inner circumstance, such as viewing one's self as someone who has to become a world savior or the next Bill Gates, presenting a false face to everyone (result? feeling completely isolated and unknown), the choice to embrace a victim mindset, self-pity, and sometimes "too high standards" which is masking a lack of empathy for fellow people as individuals.