4 ms·
He isn't talking about medication, he is talking about CBT. CBT on it's own has been shown to be effective for low to moderate depression.
by hedwall 14y ago
He isn't talking about medication, he is talking about CBT. CBT on it's own has been shown to be effective for low to moderate depression.
- DanBC 14y agoYou are speaking to someone who claims that psychiatrists are responsible for the holocaust, pearl harbour, etc etc.
- Buzaga 14y agostraw-man, ad hominem One thing is clear to me, discussing psychiatry is already a MAJOR TABOO... e.g.: in the article the dude says how he "thinks it has something to do with chemistry... and stuff" clearly in a not-so-scientific reasoning(not that all must be) but just pointing out this sort of questionings leads to major downvoting
- DanBC 14y agoCan you not see that there is a huge difference between "questioning the effectiveness of psychiatry" and "blaming psychiatry for the holocaust"? I'm more than happy to ignore people who use the propaganda from a cult where anything from psychiatry is ignored.
- Buzaga 14y agok, agree, I don't want nothing to do with Scientology also, but it's still straw-man to picture everyone who is questioning as a scientologist
- DanBC 14y ago> but it's still straw-man to picture everyone who is questioning as a scientologist But that's not what I did. I responded to someone who posted scientology propaganda.
- chris_wot 14y agoScientology is absurd. You'll have to forgive me if someone such as myself, who suffers from depression, don't find that the assertions made by a cult to be something I take very seriously. By all means, criticize psychiatry. However, I've not seen anything substantive raised in any of the discussions in any of the threads so far.