Yes. If a placebo has active ingredients, you have no chance to replicate the study if you can't tell what those active ingredients are. And if you can't replic

Yes. If a placebo has active ingredients, you have no chance to replicate the study if you can't tell what those active ingredients are. And if you can't replicate a published study from the details given in the paper, then it's not a scientific study, it's bullshit. Yes, that's right, it's bullshit. And yes most studies fall into this category. Can't be replicated, shouldn't have been accepted for publication in the first place.