4 ms·
The problem with this type of issue is that the topic is complex, it is hard to get anything like clean evidence, people start with strong opinions, and attempt
by btilly 14y ago
The problem with this type of issue is that the topic is complex, it is hard to get anything like clean evidence, people start with strong opinions, and attempts at careful analysis immediately get derailed. We could try to reduce it to its component parts. But that fails, as Calvin points out at http://www.myconfinedspace.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/04/image_ed7vv0.gif?9d7bd4 http://www.myconfinedspace.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/04/im....
But that said, here are my personal beliefs:
- Exposure to violence in mass media (including games) is probably correlated with overall violence in life across all of society.
- The individual correlation is very, very small.
- There are widespread confusions about cause and correlation that come up over and over again.
- Long term comparisons have trouble dealing with the confounding influence of a long-term decrease in violence in our society, with possible causes from changing mores to reduced lead to parents not resorting to corporal violence to who knows what.
- No simple correlation exists between levels of gun ownership and violence in a society.
- The "assault weapons" (yeah, that term is not well defined) that get used in high profile mass shootings are, on the whole, less often used in crime or to kill people than handguns. Even if a ban was effective, it would be unlikely to produce any noticeable effect.
- There is no way that, given how polarized our politics are, that anything resembling an assault weapon ban is getting through this Congress.
- The Supreme Court in Heller made it clear that governments have limited power to regulate the kinds of arms that are available, but has not ruled on what those limits are. There is a real possibility that assault weapons bans, like the one that just passed in New York, are going to be struck down on constitutional grounds.
I now return you to your regularly scheduled argument...
- _delirium 14y agoThe "assault weapons" (yeah, that term is not well defined) that get used in high profile mass shootings are, on the whole, less often used in crime or to kill people than handguns. Even if a ban was effective, it would be unlikely to produce any noticeable effect. A corollary to this is a guess that the handful of high-profile mass shootings just aren't good proxies for violence in general. I think many people view it as the "straw the broke the camel's back", an extreme example of a general class of problems that finally got people to take the problem seriously, like the Cuyahoga River catching on fire did for water pollution. But an alternate hypothesis is that these rare events are very different (in causes and solutions) from the more common kinds of violence, so the discussion focused on these handful of anomalous data points is not very useful for figuring out how to reduce violence overall.
- btilly 14y agoExactly. A better mental illness safety net likely would reduce mass shootings. Tackling drug gang violence is more likely to have an impact on homicide rates. See http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/editorial_opinion/editorials/articles/2011/10/09/expanding_the_boston_miracle/ http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/editorial_opinion/editoria... for discussion of an approach that saves lives year in and year out, but does not reduce mass shootings.
- mattmanser 14y agoIt's when stories and comments like this come out that I realize just how alien America is sometimes. Most of this comment is nonsense. But many of you can't see that because you're American. It's quite obviously nonsense when you're outside America. On THIS issue, your politicians are absolutely nuts, your citizens are absolutely nuts. We can all tell it is utter nonsense because you can look at all the other countries in the world that don't have these weird mass murders at anywhere near the frequency per capita. All of them have violent video games. Few of them have massive gun cultures. Yet Americans are seriously debating this. It's like some crazy countrywide delusion. But it's not just your gun culture, it's something else. Who knows what part of the American psyche causes it. Perhaps it's the dark-side of the American dream. You have massive homicide rates compared to the rest of the stable developed world. When it comes to murder you're a backwards country. You're down there with Belarus and Georgia. That's really, really weird. And it's not video games. Or we'd all be joining you. So it's not really very complex at all. It's got nothing to do with video games.
- smokeyj 14y ago> Most of this comment is nonsense. But many of you can't see that because you're American. You're not even trying to sound reasonable.. is there even a point in there?
- _delirium 14y agoI've lived in both the U.S. and Europe (and have family in both places), and see it as fairly complex. I don't really see Europe as having many solutions, though, except that I do like the European economic and social-safety model better. Europe does not do well at all with violence except in pretty narrow cases: monocultural to the point of being pretty racist nation-states, with a sort of extended-family village mentality. Once you try to have any kind of diversity in Europe, people get shot, even if the differences are pretty minor! Northern Ireland, the Balkans, the French banlieues, anywhere with mixtures of populations and cultures and you've got trouble. I live in Denmark currently, and it has low overall violence, but seems to basically consider multiculturalism the root of all evil, and everyone assimilating to fit within a narrow range of acceptable Danishness as the #1 strategy to keep everyone from harming their neighbor. Seems like a pretty depressing approach to peacefulness. And on the high-profile mass-shooting cases, there's little difference at all: Europe has its Utøyas and Erfurts, too. There's a lot less drug-war going on, though, or at least whatever drug trafficking is going on is more out of sight.
- dclowd9901 14y agoThanks for your personal beliefs. Who are you?
- btilly 14y agoI just updated my profile with a little bit of information. The rest you can find with Google.