4 ms·
For compiling legacy code. Found a library that does exactly what you need, but it uses ATL somewhere in its guts? Sorry, won't compile with Visual Studio Expre
by modeless 14y ago
For compiling legacy code. Found a library that does exactly what you need, but it uses ATL somewhere in its guts? Sorry, won't compile with Visual Studio Express.
- untog 14y agoI'd argue that isn't really the use case for their free tools. They want you to make ASP.NET web sites, Windows Phone apps and maybe a few simple desktop apps.
- modeless 14y agoI'm sure that's their argument too. "Express isn't 'for' that." However, Microsoft is not really in a position now to dictate what developers "should" be using Windows/Visual Studio for. If they want Windows to remain relevant as a platform then putting roadblocks in front of developers is the wrong thing to do, even if the roadblocks are well-intentioned "steering" towards a development path Microsoft prefers.
- tracker1 14y agoBut most people using the express versions probably aren't building these types of applications.. Also, the download size is important here. You can download the developer libraries GP refers to separately IIRC... Windows SDK etc.
- modeless 14y agoThe free Windows SDK doesn't include ATL/MFC either, for several versions now. You have to comb through the Microsoft Download Center archives to find an old download that happens to still have it. (For anyone who's actually looking, you can get it from, of all things, the Windows Driver Kit, version 7.1.0 and below only. http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/download/details.aspx?id=11800 http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/download/details.aspx?id=1180... ) Download size is not an issue because Visual Studio Express is primarily installed through a <1MB installer stub these days. You can choose the options you want and it only downloads what you select.
- corresation 14y agoHowever, Microsoft is not really in a position now to dictate what developers "should" be using Windows/Visual Studio for. Microsoft's developer tools have been a fairly lucrative part of their business. They are entirely within their rights, and with a robust, well-justified business case, segmenting the way they do. I would love to have everything for free as well, but the real world doesn't always work that way. Intel sells their compiler suite for $1000 or so, it's worth noting. All so you can buy their chips.
- mhurron 14y agoVS Express isn't exactly aimed at supporting legacy code for you. The Express products are free, light(er)weight and don't support everything the other editions do. You should have known this going into this. There are however other library downloads from Microsoft that may make both MFC and ATL libraries available to the Express editions.
- modeless 14y agoI know that Express isn't "aimed" at supporting legacy code. What I'm saying is, that's a bad product decision by Microsoft at a crucial time when they can't afford to alienate any developer who's still interested in developing for their platforms. I'm not saying that Microsoft should actively support new development in MFC/ATL. All I'm saying is that they shouldn't delete ATL/MFC from the Express SKU. It's true that it's still possible to get ATL/MFC in the free Platform SDKs for (much) older versions of Windows, but finding and installing it and integrating it with Visual Studio is a royal pain, and Microsoft won't tell you how to do it (or even that it's possible). And there's no way to get PIX for Direct3D 11.1 without paying $400+.