3 ms·
Same community or not, it is a fact that in each government's view, we are all 'the citizenry' under those legal jurisdictions. That means that, while you may l
by contingencies 14y ago
Same community or not, it is a fact that in each government's view, we are all 'the citizenry' under those legal jurisdictions. That means that, while you may label Kim a Trade Unionist, a Socialist or a Jew, if you deny him rights your own are worthless.
Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety. — Benjamin Franklin, 1755.
The point is that even if Kim is an asshole and a pillaging brigand, he is one of our own, the citizens. Even if he breaks the spirit of a law (and I am not sure that he does: perhaps that achievement goes to the copyright lobby), far greater criminals are the beastly, sprawling mass that is government, commercial mass media, global finance, and perhaps the science of public relations. We are all but one exploitable citizenry (or shall I say, 'human resource', 'consumer' or 'market'?) under them. And quite frankly, if Kim fights for the dissuasion of IP, it is not a great stretch to say that he fights in part for the same cause as Aaron did, albeit in different ways, and with monetary benefit. That is not necessarily stupid or evil, actually, IMHO, it's pretty damn smart: in other words, a really good hack.
After all, the law is the law. It is a system. Legal systems have been exploited since time immemorial. (I am sure there are lawyers reading this) Private citizens and large corporations exploit it regularly (a phenomenon particularly associated with modern American culture, but also multinationals). What we must not do is allow governments, the same governments raising omnipresent surveillance against us, to evade the spirit of the law, when they are supposed to be serving us... and not the other way around. For should we allow that, there is no easy way to go back... and some within this community would argue that it is almost upon us.
Remember, if the society you argue for is one in which it is not possible to break the law without being caught, then the society you are arguing for is totalitarian.
To quote Assange once more (sorry, he is far too well focused on these matters to avoid referencing): I have a view that we are dealing with really tremendously big economic and political forces, as Jérémie said, and the likely outcome is that the natural efficiencies of surveillance technologies compared to the number of human beings will mean that slowly we will end up in a global totalitarian surveillance society — by totalitarian I mean a total surveillance — and that perhaps there will just be the last free living people, those who understand how to use this cryptography to defend against this complete, total surveillance, and some people who are completely off-grid, neo-Luddites that have gone into the cave, or traditional tribes-people who have none of the efficiencies of a modern economy and so their ability to act is very small. — Julian Assange, Cypherpunks, 2012.