3 ms·
I think nickblack's original point was lost because you had related points you wanted to make. I think what he was getting at is that Facebook is a good social
by scott_s 18y ago
I think nickblack's original point was lost because you had related points you wanted to make. I think what he was getting at is that Facebook is a good social networking site that's trying to integrate applications. Google has a good set of applications, and they may try to integrate social networking.
They're approaching it from different angles. I don't think Google has to replace Facebook to succeed. If you use a lot of Google applications, you may benefit from those being plugged into a social network. But that social network doesn't have to replace ones you're already a part of (specifically, Facebook).
I also don't understand why, exactly, you think Google has bad design. It has been a pleasure to use every Google application I've tried.
- unalone 18y agoThere's an attitude here (I thought nickblack had it, too) that says Google will beat Facebook. I wanted to make the argument that that's not going to happen. I also don't understand why, exactly, you think Google has bad design. It has been a pleasure to use every Google application I've tried. Their design is better than a lot of design, but it's not good. I get pleasure from them when they're ahead of the curve: they've never made an app comparable to an existing thing that's a pleasure to use. Google Docs doesn't make text pretty, it has too much clutter, and it makes meaningless design decisions. Gmail has little nitpicky design things that feel like toothaches. (I hate that the messages get put into little blue sandwiches, and I hate the font they use for the writing in between.) The only Google product whose design I really like is their search, and that's because they got it nearly right the first time.
- nikblack 18y agoGoogle don't have to beat Facebook, its Facebook who have to beat Google, who currently have a major advantage. If Google can build their own social graph and have their applications run on top of it - there is less of a reason for users to hang around at Facebook. Google are defending from a dominant position, which is always easier.