4 ms·
Travel and green card are different things. The issue is that welfare state is fundamentally incompatible with free immigration (you can't tax American rich eno
by smsm42 14y ago
Travel and green card are different things. The issue is that welfare state is fundamentally incompatible with free immigration (you can't tax American rich enough to keep 7 billion people on American standards of living, and even if you could, it wouldn't work politically). So travel, beyond terrorism concerns and so on, is not much of a problem. My passport, for example, allows me to travel all Europe and most of the Americas without ever asking any visas. Immigration though is a different matter.
- jessaustin 14y agoWorking immigrants, documented or not, pay far more in taxes than they extract in benefits. They all live somewhere, so their landlords pay property tax from their rent. They all buy things in stores, so they pay sales tax. Those who have fake Social Security numbers pay payroll taxes, but like all of us under 45 will never see a dime in return. I'm sure you can find some oddball exception like Obama's undocumented Auntie Z who lives high on the hog in some palatial public housing unit in Boston, but these indict stupid entitlement programs more than lax immigration. I'm not claiming that limiting entitlements to immigrants is in any way unfair. If they don't like the deal they can move back home. I do object to this topic as a specious support for the "War on Immigration".
- smsm42 14y agoWorking immigrants - yes. But if we allow free immigration with full access to welfare state benefits, it would create great incentive for people that can not or do not want to work to move into the US. Let's say you like to live in Elbonia, but you got sick and Elbonian healthcare sucks. So you move to America and sign up for health insurance (remember, we now prohibit insurance companies from charging high premiums an discriminating on the basis of existing conditions?) or get a free Medicare benefits. Or maybe, Elbonian government, being smart, even buys you a ticket - so you would not burden Elbonian welfare system but would burden American one. For how long such model would be sustainable for America? >>>> but these indict stupid entitlement programs more than lax immigration. That's my whole point - entitlement programs and free immigration can not coexist. We will have to choose one or the other. Most welfare states choose the former. >>>> I do object to this topic as a specious support for the "War on Immigration". There's no such thing. Thousands of people legally immigrate to US each year, and there's no serious politician that opposes immigration as such.
- jessaustin 14y agoif we allow free immigration with full access to welfare state benefits Why on Earth would we do that? Stupid entitlement programs coupled with expanded immigration might be problematic, but there is no moral principle that states we must have stupid entitlement programs. It's not as though we drop entitlements from airplanes; people have to sign up for them using real official documents. It wouldn't be difficult to say e.g. "no Section 8 housing for people on a work visa". If you don't like entitlements then free immigration would be a good argument to use in recruiting nativists to your side. Immigration for a wide range of potential Americans we'd be wise to welcome is far more difficult now than it was fifteen years ago. That is why it's a "War on": the prison, LEO union, and armaments lobbyists only get paid when they make our authoritarian oppression more extreme than it already is. Cf. the Wars on Drugs, Terror, etc.
- smsm42 14y agoHow could we not? If the immigrant becomes full citizen, he must have access to universal healthcare, social welfare, entitlement programs, etc. That's his right as a citizen. As for entitlement programs being stupid - maybe you have in your pocket some other America, with different entitlement programs, that you could whip out and replace this one, but for me there's only one here, and it this America entitlement programs are what they are, and seeing the current political scene, are not going to substantially change, at least not for the better. >>>> It wouldn't be difficult to say e.g. "no Section 8 housing for people on a work visa" It would be. Section 8 is introduced because people feel that poor people that can not afford housing need to be helped. If you don't help poor people that can not afford housing, there's no point of having Section 8, so once these people are here, there always will be a push to provide them with the same benefits - for exactly the same reasons we provide other people with the same benefits. Poor people do not need shelter less because of visa status, and do not suffer less. If you do not want to tolerate such suffering in America - you would have to provide the benefits. >>>> Immigration for a wide range of potential Americans we'd be wise to welcome is far more difficult now than it was fifteen years ago Could you back it up with some data? As somebody who recently went though an immigration process and who have read a lot of immigration forums tracking what happens in the process, I got the impression the matters are actually improving lately (and they were not very good not because of some conspiracy but because of huge inefficient bureaucracy, which were made slightly more efficient in later years). In any case, I am seeing every day dozens of people who successfully immigrated in recent years. In what aspect it is "far more difficult now"?