4 ms·
HDDs with an SSD cache, but rather SSD/HDD hybrids that intelligently move data from one to the other) Sounds like a cache. Care to elaborate? yes, we're sadl
by angersock 14y ago
HDDs with an SSD cache, but rather SSD/HDD hybrids that intelligently move data from one to the other)
Sounds like a cache. Care to elaborate?
yes, we're sadly not using ZFS but that's in all likelihood due to licensing restrictions, not because Apple thinks HFS+ doesn't need replacing.
With the amount of cash on hand that they have, this does not fly.
Can we stop pretending that Apple's tech is as good as their design and marketing? It's okay to have average tech in a nice, well-made package--the rest of the developers aren't going to make fun of you, don't worry.
- simonh 14y agoIt's tiered storage, previous only used in extremely expensive enterprise storage infrastructure. The canonical location for frequently used blocks of data is the SSD, and no data is duplicated on both drives (except while copying of course). I have one in my new Mac Mini and I'm very happy with it. Combined with Time Machine backups it makes for a very efficient, very reliable consumer storage setup.
- DannyBee 14y agoTiered storage was available if you wanted it, it just has its own issues that don't necessarily make it better. It's not going to be faster than caching[1] and suffers from a lot of potential data loss scenarios. Yes, you get your 32 or 64 gig of SSD back, but who cares? Tiered storage is used in enterprise environments to maximize the use of expensive fast storage, or insanely cheap very slow storage. Like say, really really high end PCI express based cards, or really cheap but high latency tape drives. However, this makes a lot less sense in a consumer environment where consumer SSD prices are dropping 50% year over year. http://camelcamelcamel.com/OCZ-Technology-Vertex-2-5-Inch-VTX3-25SAT3-240G/product/B004QJM1HG http://camelcamelcamel.com/OCZ-Technology-Vertex-2-5-Inch-VT... They also make a lot less sense with only two tiers anyway. So, to review, 1. Unlike the original claim, "fusion drives" are not new technology, or pioneering (since, as you point out, it's been available in enterprise storage systems for quite a while) 2. It's not clear it's actually better than the caching system others use. 3. It's not clear it makes financial sense. [1] On the read side, you could use the same algorithm for deciding to move to cache as oyu do in tiered storage, and get identical performance. On the write side, you can use the SSD as a data journal and perform writes as fast as you can write to SSD. In a tiered storage model, all storage usually starts out on the "normal" tier, so writes will be slower, reads may be faster. If they use some weirder model (like data journaling to ssd), then it becomes equivalent to cache (in both time and space usage, not just time) , not "better".
- cmatthias 14y agoI'm convinced that Apple wants you to think that SSD prices are still where they were in 2010-2011, both to sell you the "Fusion Drive" baloney and to make it seem like paying $900 for an UPGRADE to a 512GB SSD[1] is in any way reasonable. [1] http://store.apple.com/us/configure/MD104LL/A http://store.apple.com/us/configure/MD104LL/A?
- simonh 14y ago>Tiered storage was available if you wanted it .. Really? I could have got tiered storage on my new sub-$1000 computer I got last month? Which vendor could I get that from, Dell, Hp, Acer? >It's not clear it's actually better than the caching system others use.... It's just a different technology with different characteristics, it's not a question of better or worse. One obvious benefit is that you get the sum of the two drive's capacity. Also the two drives are on two different drive connections, not a single connection to a combined device, so there may be bandwidth efficiencies as well. But you just sit there stewing in your own distain. God forbid that anyone try anything different or unusual, that's got to be bad, right?
- DannyBee 14y ago1. I think you are projecting a bit here. You come off as slightly crazed. 2. I never claimed it was cheap, i objected to acting like this technology is new. It's quite widely used in the enterprise world. 3. The cache model has the drives on two different connections as well. See Intel's Rapid Storage Technology. 4. I think i refuted the idea that the sum of the two drives capacity is useful in the current market (it's slower and not cheaper enough). 5. I'm all for different or unusual. I object to them choosing a marketing buzzword and pretending they've come up with some heretofore unthought of technology. I think I made that clear when I objected to calling it pioneering or new technology.
- Osmium 14y ago> Sounds like a cache. Care to elaborate? Data is duplicated with a cache, so you lose disk space. Edit: explained better by simonh. > With the amount of cash on hand that they have, this does not fly. Regarding licensing issues, here's a source: http://arstechnica.com/apple/2009/10/apple-abandons-zfs-on-mac-os-x-project-over-licensing-issues/ http://arstechnica.com/apple/2009/10/apple-abandons-zfs-on-m... > Can we stop pretending that Apple's tech is as good as their design and marketing? It's okay to have average tech in a nice, well-made package--the rest of the developers aren't going to make fun of you, don't worry. I'm not sure I understand this comment.
- angersock 14y ago"Lose disk space"? That seems rather silly--especially since spinning rusty glass storage is so cheap.