4 ms·
> Time Machine Silently Excludes Critical Data Sorry, but you simply didn't read the docs when setting up backup of your critical data. It's explicit that Time
by stcredzero 14y ago
> Time Machine Silently Excludes Critical Data
Sorry, but you simply didn't read the docs when setting up backup of your critical data. It's explicit that Time Machine does not back up removable drives. Try: http://www.bombich.com/ http://www.bombich.com/
EDIT: Apparently, this runs deeper. Time Machine mistakenly marks his internal drives as removables. However, he also states that he's done lots of system modding and that he has 10 internal drives. I don't think he's the target user TM was designed for. I'm not either. I have also had some TM problems and now use CCC as my primary backup, with TM as a convenience and secondary backup.
> Finder Refuses to Delete 'Backup Items'
Author states he uses OS X for serious work, and implies he has the technical wherewithal to evaluate OS X's stability and coding excellence. Apparently, he's not a programmer, or not one competent enough to use lsof and kill.
> Bottom line: Fusion as-is and as supplied by Apple is OK (maybe, hard to say for sure in multi-drive systems). Other than that, messing around carries some ugly risks.
Sorry, but if you mod your setup, then you should look in the mirror when you complain. For what you want to do there, you should be using diskutil corestorage on the command line. However, the diskutil GUI doesn't tell end users everything about corestorage yet, and I agree that this is bad. It contravenes expectations established by Disk Utility and OS X in the past -- without sufficiently warning users.
- chmars 14y agoWhat's the connection between a complaint about Time Machine's silent exclusion of critical data and Time Machine's missing support for removable drives?
- X-Istence 14y agoYo dawg I heard you like backups so I made a backup of your backup on your backup. The idea here is that Time Machine is generally not useful on transient drives that come and go, thus for each time that you plug in the drive Time Machine would have to re-scan the entire drive looking for changes, to then back those changes up to yet another external drive. Time Machine is meant to protect the files on your computer, not those on external media. Do I agree with that? No, I think I should be able to specify that Disk A should have a Time Machine backup on Disk B, and that Disk A and B are stationary to my desk, but most people don't need that. There is no requirement for that, people want to backup their main hard drive to an external so that in case something goes wrong their data is safe. The authors complaint seems to stem from the fact that Time Machine can't find a drive to backup to (which BTW, Time Machine will warn you about every single day that it is unable to backup), probably because he spent an awful amount of time partitioning his drives in weird ways with weird names, and copying stuff back and forth thereby probably getting all drives tagged by Time Machine as not viable for a backup location. -- Personally I haven't had any issues with Time Machine. I've got it setup over iSCSI to an OpenIndiana host and to a local 1TB external drive and all is well, haven't had any issues what so ever with it no backing up data, and restoring has been a breeze in the past.
- mrgoldenbrown 14y agoI don't think he's talking about removable drives - he claims internal drives are getting added to the exclusion list. Details here: http://macperformanceguide.com/Mac-TimeMachine-exclude-bug.html http://macperformanceguide.com/Mac-TimeMachine-exclude-bug.h...
- stcredzero 14y agoYeah, that's bad, but I get the sense that he's doing some core storage stuff he shouldn't be doing. 10 internal drives? And he should know better than to use the Disk Utility GUI for serious corestorage operations.
- kenko 14y ago"I don't think he's the target user TM was designed for." Because he has a lot of drives? What?
- Zarathust 14y agoIn the Apple ecosystem, "modding" includes adding drives and is not recommended
- stcredzero 14y agoAdding drives is fine. Adding drives, plus multiple esoteric volume manager gymnastics is not. (You know what that is?)
- msbarnett 14y agoBecause he's been mucking around with core storage volumes and drive bay extenders to the point that certain of his internal drives look like they're on an external bus to the OS. Apple optimizes for the common case, which he's way outside.