7 ms·
Why extroverts fail, introverts flounder and you probably succeed
- rosenweiss 14y agoDisgusting.
- jgw 14y agoYou maintained a vow of silence for 225 days, and then broke it to write... this? That's quite fascinating, actually.
- Toenex 14y agoThis made me laugh so much a little bit of wee came out.
- fuck_google 14y agoThis made me laugh so much a little bit of crap came out. Reminds me of the recent product announcements by Google.
- bjhoops1 14y agoWell, this makes me feel better about wondering for years whether I was really an introvert or in fact an extrovert. Now I can be proud to claim the term "ambivert"!
- jgw 14y agoI wondered about this, too. I took a Meyers-Briggs test as a team-building exercise once, and in the I-E continuum, I fell very mildly on the Introvert side. But there are sub-categories in each of the fields, and I scored full marks for "gregariousness". So I've spent the last few years wondering what a gregarious introvert is. I think it's someone who laughs very loudly at their own jokes.
- silverbax88 14y agoTo be honest, most people have a completely incorrect view of introverts. Many stand up comedians are introverts. Many artists are introverts. Being an introvert is not the same as shy.
- donatzsky 14y agoThat's something I've noticed myself, being something of an introvert. On a number of occasions I've been "accused" of being timid, which I'm not, although I guess it might come across that way. Or perhaps it's just that introvert is a difficult word :)
- wisty 14y agoHere's my copy-pasta: MBTI is braindead pop-science which is based on the rantings of Jung. It was good for the time (when measuring people's skulls to determine their personality was popular) but has no place in modern science. The biggest problem is, it's deliberately polarising. Jung thought there were fundamental personality types, and that everyone would fall into a specific box. That's good if you want to write a "what career is best for you" article for Cosmo, or for school kids. But it's bad science. Most personality traits are normally distributed, not categorial. Most people are ambiverts, not introverts or extrovert. There's plenty of people who are heavily introverted, and plenty of people who are heavily extroverted, and it's useful to have a word for it, but most people aren't. The other problem is, the traits it measures aren't important. Big 5 (Introversion, Openness to experience (i.e. culture / intelligence), Conscientiousness, Agreeableness, and Neuroticism) is better. It uses more interesting traits, and puts them on a scale (rather than using categories). It's not perfect (there's no real model, it's just common factors in personalities - psychologists often say it's overrated) but it's much better than MBTI.
- danielharan 14y agoThe article only talks about correlating Introversion to sales ability, so big 5 or MBTI wouldn't terribly matter. Further, in this case they used a different, 7 point scale.
- rm999 14y agoAs someone who is ambi in several of those categories I still think there's utility in the classifications. It's definitely pop-pseudo-science, but I'm not convinced proper science can even distill something as complex as personality into something a lay person can understand. Maybe it's the best most people will do in understanding themselves. A friend of mine who also recognizes the pseudo-scientific nature of MBTI put it well: use the test to pinpoint where people may differ from you and learn why they do. He claims he has almost mastered all eight letters (he still stuggles with T), and I have to say that he is one of the most well-balanced people I know. Personally, the test revealed to me why people may think I come off as arrogant (it apparently comes with the J and T), which I have become more aware of in my interaction with others.
- 14y ago
- notahacker 14y agoMyers Briggs aims to measure preference rather than performance. A score highly biased towards extroversion is just as likely to indicate a weakness in "introverted" areas, such as approaching problems strategically, as it is to indicate a strength in communication skills. A better rule of thumb when looking for the right qualities in a salesperson, especially a complex-software-solving-complex-problem salesperson, is to look for someone that listens to the other party more than they talk.
- at-fates-hands 14y agoThis is how sales has changed drastically over the past 10-15 years. Before, high pressure sales and using hard closing techniques have been replaced by a more "consultative" approach. IT's a more humanistic approach to selling your company wares. Because of this, listening, or the appearance of listening has become the new training tool for salespeople. As such, using an extroverted or introverted label doesn't really apply.
- albedoa 14y agoThe article casts a wide net for what defines an ambivert: Ambiverts [...] are people who are neither extremely introverted nor extremely extroverted. What can we really say about this third group if we are including everyone who is not an extreme example of the other two?
- grinnick 14y agoHere’s the best part, however. The distribution of introverts and extroverts in the population looks eerily like the results Grant found plotting revenue across his 1-to-7 scale. Some of us are heavy introverts. Some of us are stalwart extroverts. But the vast majority of us are ambiverts. Surely these results could be explained by saying that we are better at selling to people who are like us then? Assuming there are few extroverts or introverts but lots of ambiverts in a population of sales people and the same distribution is found in the people being sold to. If we are better at selling to people similar to ourselves then the ambiverts chosen for the experiment will perform well in a wider segment of the population and hence make more sales.
- sayemm 14y agoLink-bait title for a mildly interesting study. I'm not surprised at the results, anyone with real sales/biz dev experience will tell you that listening and asking the right questions are the way to sell people, not "hustling" and being overly salesy/pushy - http://www.amazon.com/SPIN-Selling-Neil-Rackham/dp/0070511136/ http://www.amazon.com/SPIN-Selling-Neil-Rackham/dp/007051113... That said though, how you define yourself as "extroverted", "introverted", or an "ambivert" is questionable altogether.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- keithpeter 14y ago> "The distribution of introverts and extroverts in the population looks eerily like the results Grant found plotting revenue across his 1-to-7 scale." 'Ambiverts' make better marriages?
- deltasquared 14y agoSomething sounds off here. At face value the article is saying. If most people are "ambiverts" and ambiverts make the best sales people, and sales people are the best leaders, why are there not more leaders? Why is it that most people are not in charge. Finding out that there is no correlation between extroversion and sales performance is interesting and all but I think it would be better to find a new scale to use, one with positive correlation for what you are looking for. Pointing out that people's scores for extroversion fall along a normal distribution, and that people's sales preform aces fall along a normal distribution does not really say much. Typically, a low correlation score means your model is wrong, not that you need to fix your model by choosing a different locus.