6 ms·
The EU-funded plan to stick a “flag this as terrorism” button in your browser
- nextparadigms 14y agoThey must've stolen this "brilliant" idea from Lieberman. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20111125/14202016898/sen-joe-lieberman-asks-google-report-blog-as-terrorist-button.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20111125/14202016898/sen-j...
- flexxaeon 14y agoOr Robot Chicken http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Srv_V3-oqsc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Srv_V3-oqsc
- venomsnake 14y agoTypical braindead EU bureaucracy at action. I expect illegal crypto laws soon. That is the problem with regulators - first they regulate sane stuff. Everybody benefits from clean water and food. Then we regulate the semi sane stuff - like how much space a cow need and what is humane - well that makes some sense. It may not be the urgent problems, but animal cruelty is bad. And then when they run out, just to keep the staff employed and budgets growing they try to regulate unregulatable stuff. Just put that unfiltered, unmonitored and encrypted internet is a human right. And then hear the scream of the bureaucracy.
- halvsjur 14y agoEver expanding bureaucracy is a problem, and the EU has a track record of turning several truly idiotic ideas into law. But people discussing EU regulations should be aware that the level of bullshit and outright lies coming out of the UK press in this regard is staggering. Some nice examples: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqVJEZnYiZo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqVJEZnYiZo
- jasonm23 14y ago"level of bullshit and outright lies coming out of the UK press" ... ...staggering would imply a degree of shock. They've been doing this since the EU/ECM began.
- Feint1 14y agoThe worst bit is that there's actually a chance it'll pass into law. I remember laughing about the proposed cookie law and the incandescent light bulb ban before they actually managed to successfully get both through the European Parliament. I hope the British people do get a referendum on Europe soon. We've had enough of this rubbish.
- gpcz 14y agoHow quickly do you think the button will go away when some malware author writes something that flags every site a person goes on as a terrorist site (or some activist makes a voluntary browser plugin)?
- russell 14y agoOr botnet, or terrorist organization goes about flagging the 1 million most popular sites?
- pvaldes 14y agoSo, now you can flag your stupid ex-boyfriend or your unwary buddy as terrorist and have some laughs with only a simple clic, wow... No need to search for a phone box anymore! Brilliant!
- Cogito 14y agoTo be fair, as one commentator notes, “this document—in this phase— [is] nothing more than a status report without strong countermeasures against terrorism.” They propose a potential method to combat terrorism online, as they were chartered to do, but note how difficult such a task would be and also how ineffective it is likely to be. Some points from the document, quoted in the article: • The Internet is not a single virtual society governed by one system of rule of law. • It is often difficult to determine which content on the Internet is illegal, also because illegality depends on the context in which it is presented and can differ worldwide and even between EU Member States. • EU and Member States legislation and jurisdiction covers only a part of the Internet. • Illegal content itself does not always lead to radicalization and terrorist acts, while content that does contribute to radicalization is not always illegal. • Many activities of (potential) terrorists start in ordinary, easy accessible parts of the Internet and are not illegal. I don't think it is wrong to investigate how to mitigate organised crime and terrorism on the internet; the real concern is the cost in doing so, and what comes from such investigation. From how it stands now I doubt the proposal to implement a 'report terrorism' button will precipitate.
- JulianMorrison 14y ago"The remains of Mr Smith, of 59 Pringleton Crescent, were today identified in the ruins of his house. Mr Smith was killed when an automated anti-terrorist drone fired a missile through his bedroom window. Authorities are refusing to confirm or deny the rumour that his death was caused by an internet prank, as his stamp-collecting site was repeatedly flagged as terrorist material by members of the discussion site 4chan."
- JakeSc 14y agoThat seems pretty unrealistic. No developed country would use drones to kill people based solely on accusation, forgoing their right to a fair trial.
- sesqu 14y agoI can't tell if you're being sarcastic. If not, you may want to read up on prominent cases like Anwar al-Awlaki's assassination.
- JakeSc 14y agoPerhaps it was inappropriate for HN, but I was absolutely being sarcastic. Thanks for pointing this out for others anyway. I'm sickened by these "targeted assassinations", regardless of how effective they are at protecting our Homeland.
- biot 14y ago> No developed country would ... [forego] their right to a fair trial. My sarcasm detector is returning a superposition of both 0 and 1 with your comment. It must have something to do with the quantanumo uncertainty principle.
- JulianMorrison 14y agoSince there won't be a trial, that superposition could continue indefinitely.
- 14y ago
- eksith 14y agoBecause people are already so good at differentiating crass arguments from just plain ol' trolling right? Just the mere implication would be enough for some ISPs to pull the plug on certain sites as they really can't be bothered to take on cyberbullying (by people is a cakewalk, it's different when governments do it). So censoring a disagreeable site is the least stressful method for them. And I wonder how this will work with .onion sites... Oh, right. They'll just jail node ops.
- Irishsteve 14y agoThey could have just bought delicious.com that way there would be stake for different types of terrorism. The whole process woulda cost 1 million USD right?
- donall 14y agoThe picture example in the article is of an Irish terrorist group. Interestingly, supporters of this group are quite likely to flag official UK government, police and armed forces groups as terrorist web sites. Then again, an even greater number of people will flag sites like Facebook and Google, for "humour value". If this does become a "feature", I only hope that they will publish statistics on what has been flagged.
- saosebastiao 14y agoSounds like the perfect platform for trolling.
- sageikosa 14y agoI suppose if you crowd-source wild accusations, then anything becomes justifiable with enough up-votes. Welcome to the Reign of Terror 21st century style.