3 ms·
Actually, it's only true to the degree they copy bits of code. The question whether conforming to a given API (which is what wordpress themes really do) consti
by DannyBee 14y ago
Actually, it's only true to the degree they copy bits of code.
The question whether conforming to a given API (which is what wordpress themes really do) constitutes a derivative work has so far only been answered "no" (and honestly, you better hope it stays that way).
GPL explicitly states that non-derivative works are not covered.
That said, basically, wordpress takes a legal position that is pretty bad, IMHO.
People copying the GPL code into their own code?
Great, i'm with you, it's GPL'd, assuming
1. it's copyrightable code.
2. it's not the only way to make it compatible, since if it's the only way to make it compatible, that's so far been considered fair use.
As the ninth circuit said, anything else would grant a de-facto monopoly on functional uses.
IMHO, you really don't want the legal reality to become what wordpress is trying to enforce.
- bigiain 14y ago"IMHO, you really don't want the legal reality to become what wordpress is trying to enforce." While your explanation makes that clear (and thanks for that), there's a big difference between "our preferences should become law", and "our preferences are not supported by law, but people who don't agree with them don't get invited to speak at conferences we run". Democrats are free to run conferences without being required to allow republicans to present there and vice versa, why is that different for Wordpress's conferences? I think your choice of the word "enforce" is probably a bit of an overreach for what Wordpress are trying to do. (for what it's worth, I don't agree with what Wordpress are doing, it seems petty and small minded to me, but I do think they have every right to be petty and small minded about conferences they organize if they choose to be…)
- dangrossman 14y agoThey don't actually organize the conferences, and probably have no involvement in most of them aside from vetting those who volunteer as organizers. WordCamps are small, locally run, kind of like a big meetup (and are often first organized through meetup.com). Tickets are usually around $20, with volunteer speakers and a few sponsors to cover the meeting space. That's been my experience in this region at least.
- DannyBee 14y agoYes, enforce is probably the wrong word, though at least at one point, I do remember they used to take this position outside of conferences as well.