3 ms·
> What an interesting statement. Sounds to me like you're saying the individual is there to serve the societal structure, instead of the other way around. No,
by gnaritas 18y ago
> What an interesting statement. Sounds to me like you're saying the individual is there to serve the societal structure, instead of the other way around.
No, I think one can't exist without the other, but what I'm saying is things like trade and property don't exist outside the social structure setup by society in today's world.
> Individuals exist just fine without governments, but not the other way around.
Actually, no, they don't, because there are no individuals, there are just lot's and lot's of people and we can't get along without some form of government. With no explicit government in place, crime rules. We can all agree that criminal rule is not "getting along fine", and in fact we have, it's why we create governments to begin with.
No man is an island, we are tribal creatures, and always have been even before we were man.
> Democracy isn't some club used by the majority to tyrannize the minority.
Actually, it is exactly that. We've put protections into place in many circumstances to force a super majority to be required, but it very much is tyranny of the majority. Look at the laws around us we're all forced to obey and tell me it isn't?
America is NOT a society based on individual liberty and freedom, it IS a society based on the moral whims of the majority. If this were not the case, there would be no victimless crimes and the default position of everything would be legal and getting something made illegal would be a huge battle. This is the exact opposite of what were are now.
Interesting and enjoyable comments from you though, thanks.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoYou realize that the United States had no federal government for 12 years, from 1775 to 1787, right? And that for a large part of its history, people were responsible for their own crime control? I could go on -- at length -- about various places where people did just fine without government structure. In the old west, for instance, marshals might not make it through town but once every couple of months. Didn't seem to slow down westward expansion that much. European traders worked all over the world just on a handshake and a promise for centuries. Anthropologists studying tribes tell us that there are a few things that distinguish true tribes from modern cultures. One of those is the idea of private property: what is mine is mine and you can't take it from me unless under very unusual circumstances. In very primitive societies, the chief or the tribal elders can come around and just take what they want. It's only after we had the concept of private property and contract law that we saw significant economic and cultural growth. It was observing this state of nature that eventually created the political theory that is the bedrock of the country. In communist China, just after the revolution, they would have "people's courts". These courts basically consisted of a mob of people who would bring in rich people, describe at length how they "exploited" the workers, and then strip them of all their goods. Sometimes for good measure they'd send them to jail or kill them. It was great political theater -- the crowds loved it -- but what were the results? This was not a time of record growth, or even a time when the lives of the average citizen got that much better. All they really ended up doing was just replacing the folks who got rich signing contracts and respecting property rights with the folks who got rich being politically connected and doing whatever they liked. Just some things for you to consider. I know I don't want to see any version of people's courts here in my lifetime.
- gnaritas 18y agoNo federal government does not mean no government. Everywhere you find people you will find some form of government they have setup to resolve disputes even if that government is no more than what they consider a fair arbitrator. If we all agreed on everything we wouldn't need a government but that just isn't going to happen, ever. Yes, for short periods of time small groups of people can get along without a government. That is not relevant, we're talking about a country here and you aren't really suggesting that we could get by just fine without a government are you? Government means any ruling body, not just the feds. I don't want to see those kinds of kangaroo courts in place either, but the privilege of property, and it is a privilege, is not absolute and never has been. When necessary, we've always had some means of seizing it for the good of the many over the whims of the individual. This is as it should be. We should respect property rights as much as possible up to the point that they start hurting the many too much.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoYes, you are making my point. What happens in these cases? What happens, say, when a merchant from Venice seeks to work with an Arab trader in the 14th century? Each voluntarily gives up some sovereignty to create a minimal set of rules so that a transaction can take place. Government (at whatever level) consists of each of us voluntarily giving up some of our sovereignty so that we can have private property and contract law. The protection of our property -- our lives, our housing, our money, etc -- is the goal here. Without that protection, and without our voluntary surrender of power, government becomes something you do to somebody else. It becomes a tool of control. Jefferson was against the U.S. Constitution, for instance, for just that fear -- that by removing politicians from the people at some point you lose the heart of a democracy. Now of course we have to have a national defense, and therefore we're going to have taxes. I don't think anybody wants zero government. In fact, government can do lots of cool things, like a space program or promote clean energy. But the key question remains: are people voluntarily giving up sovereignty for freedom to transact? Or are they stuck with no choices? Is government something for maximizing freedoms, or something for equalizing property? Are we still getting equal representation for our taxation? Is government something we create, or something that we're stuck with? If property is a privilege to be taken at the whims of the majority, then we're back to the caves again.