2 ms·
I see the OP's point, that visual noise can be filtered in such a way as to create a more compelling trend, and perhaps the filtering that Gates has done has si
by danso 14y ago
I see the OP's point, that visual noise can be filtered in such a way as to create a more compelling trend, and perhaps the filtering that Gates has done has simplified the results...so, OK. Let's not look at charts, let's look at actual calculations that have the various factors accounted for...what are they?
And I guess I'll throw in my two cents into the inevitable teachers-vs-data debate. I believe teachers may be too quick to toss aside performance analysis because they are so close to the personal stories and circumstances...no line chart can seem to account for the student who was improving greatly but then missed an insurmountable number of classtime due to problems at home.
Most humans are unwilling/unable to see their lives and work measured as averages and trend lines and deterministic outcomes, and I think teachers are acutely of this belief due to the nature of their work. And unfortunately, this blinds them to the possibility that while there is no cookie-cutter solution that always works, there are surely some measures/guidelines that often work, or at least mitigate even the most extreme circumstances. As it is, there's not much incentive or opportunity to see "the bigger picture" outside of what happens in one's own classroom year after year.
That said, this is not even close to being mainly the fault of the teachers. Among the other problems is that administrators are just as prone to shortsightedness, and "the numbers" can be wielded by a petty/mediocre principal/district officer to apply pressure to a teacher. It's no wonder that teachers are quick to distrust analyses, given the possibility that they're abused for political means.
So, essentially, it's a giant crapfest with no easy solutions. From the perspective of Gates' efforts, we can only hope that he pours in so much money and advocacy that there's eventually a shift towards best practices...though it's safe to say there will still be unintended consequences that aren't all favorable.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoAmong the other problems is that administrators are just as prone to shortsightedness, and "the numbers" can be wielded by a petty/mediocre principal/district officer to apply pressure to a teacher. The more we rely on objective numbers, the less a good teacher has to fear from a bad principal. The principal has no ability to make the teacher's students do worse than their statistical predictor, after all. On the other hand, many other popular metrics (e.g. principal's opinion/coworker's opinion) can easily be tweaked by a principal who wants to put pressure on a teacher.