3 ms·
"Whereas to me it looks like it removes visual noise to show an actual trend." Except for that in this case the noise is more important than the trend. Think a
by Alex3917 14y ago
"Whereas to me it looks like it removes visual noise to show an actual trend."
Except for that in this case the noise is more important than the trend. Think about it, if you're firing or sanctioning perhaps 30%+ of teachers each year for no reason, then only complete morons would go into teaching.
It's the same as airport security, where a .1% false positive rate is unacceptable, whereas a 75% false negative rate is just fine.
- jellicle 14y agoCurrently the number of public school teachers fired or sanctioned per year is much less than 0.1%. Which is a bit different than 30%. So I'm thinking they're not too worried about this.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Alex3917 14y ago"Currently the number of public school teachers fired or sanctioned per year is much less than 0.1%." This is comparing apples and oranges.
- ryanmolden 14y agoDid you transpose false negative and false positive in your statement about airport security? I think airport security would much rather have false positive (i.e. This guy has something suspicious, let's do further checks, oh, turns out it was nothing) vs. False negatives (i.e. This guy is clean, oh, turns out he wasn't and blew up a plane).
- Alex3917 14y agoNo, that's correct. The issue is that the overwhelming majority of people aren't terrorists. So even though it's worse to let a terrorist on a plane than it is to ban someone who isn't a terrorist from flying, in aggregate the harms of banning non-terrorists from flying become greater than the harms letting a few terrorists fly even when the false positive rate is very small. Bruce Schneier has a good explanation of this somewhere on his blog. (Actually, this is one of his pet issues, so there are probably dozens of blog posts about this.)