5 ms·
Exactly! We know very little. The same goes for the atomic model and a lot of other things. Electrons, protons, quarks? That's our model. We know the equation
by raverbashing 14y ago
Exactly!
We know very little. The same goes for the atomic model and a lot of other things.
Electrons, protons, quarks? That's our model. We know the equations, we know how to predict a lot of stuff.
This guarantees nothing. Maybe tomorrow someone comes up with a different theory that explains things better but doesn't say anything about waves or particles. Who knows.
Quick example: what's a magnetic field? It is a measurable quantity, there are theories about how forces are exchanged between charged particles, but essentially it is more a mathematical aid than anything else.
And physics is the most 'hard' science. Easily reproducible, the same everywhere in the universe (as far as we know), experiments can be reproduced as many times as you want without interference.
Now if you go to more specific sciences (biology, medicine, etc) it gets worse. They are only valid on planet Earth for a short period of time, for a start. Test subjects all have differences and experimenting on them affects the results.
- jibbirish 14y agoThis is the very core of our scientific method (critical rationalism, Karl Popper [1]), theoretical models can only be used in science when they can be falsified. That is why we call them hypothesis (from the Greek word for assumption [2]). Logically, no number of positive outcomes at the level of experimental testing can confirm a scientific theory, but a single counterexample is logically decisive. For example, we can observe a thousand white swans in the world, and hypothesize that all swans are white. That is until we encounter that one black swan, and our hypothesis has been falsified. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_Popper http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_Popper [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothesis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothesis
- meaty 14y agoElegantly described!
- DougWebb 14y agoNo, the black swan is a figment of your imagination. It wasn't a swan. You didn't know what you were looking at. You made it up. I don't care that lots of people saw it, you're all delusional. You're crackpots. The problem with the scientific method is that scientists become very attached to their hypotheses, and the longer a hypothesis stands the more attached scientists get. This causes them to reject contradictory evidence, often going to ridiculous lengths to do so. A change of the hypotheses, a scientific revolution, only happens on the fringes of science when a maverick persists in examining evidence that most scientists reject.
- meaty 14y agoPrime example: climate change. We have precisely fuck all idea what is going on regardless of the models. Proof of this can be found by examining all the climate change news articles based on scientific papers going back to the impending ice age in 1972 (people have a short memory for climatology theories).
- luser001 14y agoRelevant Asimov's classic article: http://chem.tufts.edu/answersinscience/relativityofwrong.htm http://chem.tufts.edu/answersinscience/relativityofwrong.htm YMMV.
- robotresearcher 14y agoNews articles can not be relied on to present science and the views of scientists accurately. Controversy is news, consensus is not. Very few publications care enough to get their science reporting right, and it's expensive to have people on staff who are capable of doing it.
- illuminate 14y ago"Proof of this can be found by examining all the climate change news articles based on scientific papers going back to the impending ice age in 1972 (people have a short memory for climatology theories)." While it makes a good talking point, it was not the case. http://www.skepticalscience.com/ice-age-predictions-in-1970s.htm http://www.skepticalscience.com/ice-age-predictions-in-1970s...
- raverbashing 14y agoThank you, you explained better an beyond the usual repetition There's so much of this it's not even funny. The last part of my post is in this gist. But in physics this is easier to work around. In other areas not so much Also, the scientific method and Popper's ideas are a philosophical construct. One has to think: who watches the watchman?
- akiselev 14y ago
- aMoniker 14y agoCan the universe be described by a formal system, or will doing so always result in a model? If such a system exists, are the number of rules finite?
- Confusion 14y agoThis guarantees nothing. It guarantees a whole lot of things. When necessary, you bet your life on these mere 'models'. These 'models' cause you to trust stepping into an airplane and stepping out of the trajectory of a falling rock. We know very little. We know a lot about these models. We investigate where they hold and where they don't. We don't just know they are valid on planet Earth for a short period of time: we investigate whether they also hold elsewhere and held in the past and have every reason to believe they did and do. To move on to some philosophical background behind your assertion: the idea that there is some 'real', 'objective', 'true' reality that is modeled by these models, is a pre-Kantian point of view. A post-Kantian point of view is that these models of how the universe works are our reality. They are the only thing we can possibly have knowledge of: the models we use to categorize and structure our observations. Most of them only exist in our brains. They got there by nature and nurture, without us usually spelling them out. They govern our daily behavior. We've tried to formalize the more complex ones in language that is independent of individual humans. Sometimes observations are not consistent with a model, so we revise the model. Still we only know the new version of the model, which describes what we expect to observe.
- raverbashing 14y agoOf course, I don't mean 'guarantees nothing' in the sense of "planes won't fly" or things like this. These are the results that are verified. The math What we don't know about is if our model (and not the math or the results) has anything to do with "reality" (and that may not even be possible) Take the particle/wave duality for example. We're talking about an electron being 'a particle' but sometimes 'a wave'. Of course, we can predict things about the behaviour of this electron, but the story behind it, of particles, waves, may not be accurate, and this may be replaced by something that completely does away with electrons (difficult to imagine since electrons have mass) but comes with similar predictions.
- akiselev 14y agoFor all we know, we may never "describe" reality with mathematics, but it's purpose is nevertheless to estimate and predict to a certain degree of precision an event within its boundary conditions. In this sense, science and mathematics are not one and the same. The scientific method is designed to push these mathematical models past their limits so that we may get closer to discovering what this "reality" really is. These models are how we know when something doesn't fit with our scientific understanding, it is nothing more than a feedback loop. Edit: hnhg: You're right, rephrased properly :)
- tcgv 14y agoI agree with you. When ever someone argues that we know a lot about the world and how it works, the following quote comes to my mind: "The universe is not only stranger than we imagine, it is stranger than we can imagine" J. B. S. Haldane